Skip to navigation

Thecus N4200Eco review

in Storage appliances

Verdict

An affordable desktop NAS appliance, the new processor and memory deliver a clear speed boost over its precursor

Review Date: 17 Feb 2011

Reviewed By: Dave Mitchell

Price when reviewed: £585 (£702 inc VAT)

Overall Rating
5 stars out of 6

Features & Design
4 stars out of 6

Value for Money
5 stars out of 6

Performance
5 stars out of 6

Despite its model name, the latest N4200Eco from Thecus is more concerned about improving performance and value than it is about saving the planet. It takes the same chassis as the older N4200Pro model, but replaces its 1.66GHz Atom D510 with a 1.8GHz dual-core D525 processor and beefs up memory to 1GB of faster DDR3.

The N4200Eco is easy on the pocket: a diskless unit costs £349, while the 4TB model on review comes in at a very reasonable £585 exc VAT. The N4200Eco doesn’t support the battery backup module available with the N4200Pro, nor does it have the dual-DOM.

The front panel sports Thecus’ slick OLED panel and the keypad below is for manual RAID and network configuration. A colourful display at the side has status icons for the disks, Gigabit ports and USB copy function.

The setup wizard finds the appliance on the network and provides quick access to the main web console. The smart Ajax-based interface has been improved with a firmware upgrade and is simple to use.

RAID support is good, and for testing we put all four 1TB drives into a RAID5 array that took around six hours to build. The N4200Eco supports IP SANs, and you decide during volume creation the amount of space to set aside for targets, which are also simple to create.

Thecus N4200Eco

Along with extensive client support you have secure FTP services, while access security extends to a local user database plus AD authentication. Thecus also provides a wide range of free update modules with the IP Cam option, adding basic surveillance.

Synology and Qnap are better at this since they both support motion detection and live feeds. The N4200Eco can store only scheduled JPEG snapshots from up to five IP cameras at intervals of between one and 60 seconds.

The download station module can be used by the appliance to retrieve files via BitTorrent, HTTP, FTP or eMule. Along with web server and bi-directional USB copy options, Thecus offers a mail server module that loads PHPXmail.

Thecus includes Acronis’ True Image Personal, which doesn’t support Windows Server. It runs manual backups of files and folders or entire drives as images to the appliance and can create a bootable disaster recovery disk. However, the Personal version is lacking in features so, if you want job scheduling, disk cloning, incremental backups and much more, you’ll have to upgrade.

The faster processor and memory made their presence felt in our real-world speed tests with drag-and-drop copies of a large video clip over Gigabit returning read and write speeds of 81MB/sec and 72MB/sec. FTP operations were slightly faster, with the FileZilla client reporting speeds of 86MB/sec and 76MB/sec. IP SANs were on the money – Iometer showed a high raw read speed of 110MB/sec for a 50GB target.

The N4200Eco is a well-specified, quiet NAS appliance at a low price, and a top performer as well. Businesses won’t be impressed with the backup software, but the list of storage features available goes a long way to make up for this.

Author: Dave Mitchell

Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here

From around the web

User comments

Insufficient Data!

If I am to buy a NAS, this or any other model, a new substantially more comprehensive test must be designed. The device needs to be put through an exaustive list of tests.

Various tests should be setup, each to eliminate all but one aspect of the NAS, and focus on one key feature.

For example a test to determine the raw speed of the CPU/Memory (using SSD's?), the maximum throughput of the network interface(s) (using SSD's?), maximum performance of disks in various layouts 2x2disk Raid1, 1x2disk RAID1+1x2disk RAID0, RAID10, 3disk RAID5, 4disk RAID5 etc etc.

How to break a RAID array into more managable chunks of space. Only an idiot would store everything in one or a few massive filesystems, even allowing for some unresolved storage limitations! The RAID array needs to be capable of breaking into small manageable chunks that can each be used to store files, media, databases, iSCSI mapped storage, Virtual Machines, backups etc etc

What is the minimum spec (not capacity) disk that should be used for any given RAID mode, what is the maximum spec (not capacity disk that should be used for any given RAID mode.

No point in putting a single disk in let alone a full complement, if you are not going to get the best performance that the NAS is capable of.

Since these days 3.5" disks individually are capable of speeds ranging from around 65-130 MB/s it seems inconceivable that you could not run a NAS at the limits of Gigabit speeds (125MB/s per port) with 2 disks per port. RAID 5 may reduce performance marginally, however a substantial processor should be able to manage this. Let's not forget that many people use SW RAID in linux and their system with comperable processors, getting better performance than this doing much much more (and I do not forget that these people are running RAID internally but this NAS is barely able to hit the limits of one port?)!

Since the purpose of a NAS is to share space, how about some tests of concurrent access?

Finally how bout telling us the performance metrics of the test disks?

By j_woolliscroft on 17 Feb 2011

It's a review..

Not an in-depth technical appraisal of all possible aspects of a NAS box. How much time/money do you think they have available to test each piece of equipment that passes through their doors? And how much would you be willing to pay to read such an in-depth technical appraisal?

By JohnGray7581 on 18 Feb 2011

Leave a comment

You need to Login or Register to comment.

(optional)

Latest Category Reviews
Qsan Technology P300Q-D212 review

Qsan Technology P300Q-D212

Category: Storage appliances
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £5,700
Western Digital Sentinel DX4000 review

Western Digital Sentinel DX4000

Category: Storage appliances
Rating: 4 out of 6
Price: £712
Synology RackStation RS3411xs review

Synology RackStation RS3411xs

Category: Storage appliances
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £1,981
LaCie 5big Network 2 review

LaCie 5big Network 2

Category: Storage appliances
Rating: 3 out of 6
Price: £692
Compare reviews: Storage appliances

advertisement

More From PC Pro
Latest News Stories Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Features
Latest Real World Computing

advertisement

Sponsored Links
 
 
SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010
 
 

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.