Corel VideoStudio Pro X5 review
VideoStudio has a distinctly homely feel to it, but it has always been quick to keep up with the latest developments. In 2007 it introduced Blu-ray and AVCHD authoring before any other consumer software. This year’s trail-blazing feature is HTML5 authoring.
This restores the menu navigation functions that users have lost as they move from optical media to the web to distribute their videos. Adobe Premiere Elements already provides this using Flash, but HTML5 is a better choice with its wider device support. VideoStudio uses the HTML5 canvas element, with a background video layer and image and text overlays. These overlays can act as links, either to chapter markers within the timeline or external URLs.
Sadly, VideoStudio’s HTML5 output has its problems. Playback didn’t commence automatically, leaving us to click Play on the transport bar after selecting a chapter from the top menu. There’s no way to stop playback from looping, either. External links opened in a new browser tab, which isn’t so useful for jumping between pages on a site.
When we started from a template, chapter links jumped to the wrong places, although this problem disappeared when we started from scratch. One project’s links worked fine when viewed on an iPad, but another’s got trapped in a perpetual loop. The transport progress bar didn’t work on the iPad, and musical accompaniments encoded in Ogg Vorbis format didn’t play.
The HTML5-authoring tools could be better, too. Rather than rework the DVD-authoring module, Corel has created a new HTML5 project type, with graphics and links arranged on the timeline. This served to remind us that VideoStudio’s timeline controls are cumbersome when it comes to manipulating lots of objects across multiple tracks. Ripple editing is overly complex, and can’t be switched off altogether, despite what the interface suggests. It isn’t possible to reorder tracks, and there are only two dedicated tracks for text objects.
Our biggest frustration is that, for HTML5 projects, effects and transitions are only available for the video tracks, and not for graphics on the overlay tracks. We tried to use the new HTML5 features to produce an animated slideshow and export it as JPEGs and a music file rather than a video. It worked to a point, but without access to the Pan & Zoom effect, transitions or even any way to rotate portrait-shaped photos, it didn’t live up to expectations.
Poor editing and help
I tired the demo. There's no way to accurately align the waveform of a video and a separate audio track, i.e. as needed when making a music video. Trial and error is not the way to make detailed sync edits. Used the Help 'ask me' - useless.
By SkylineUK on 25 May 2012
My client uses this software. Every movie file he sent me was, in some way, broken. I assumed it was dumb user error so I downloaded the demo.
The user might indeed be a bit dumb (bless 'im ... lovely fellow, not too good with computers) but that wasn't the problem ... it really is this horrible bit of software ... no matter what I did the videos wouldn't work properly until I downloaded a freebie bit of conversion software.
I used all the same output settings as the original export from corel and simply put the 'corel made' file through that ... the file that came out the other side was much smaller and it worked.
And that's before I lay into the awful interface and limited options!
This is the nastiest new software experience that I can remember having so far this century. I wasted a week before figuring out that it wasn't me (it usually is), it really was a problem with the software.
By slyme1 on 31 May 2012
I can clip a video and save in, say, around 4 ish different video sizes and formats... They all play perfectly fine.
Maybe it is you? :)
By rhythm on 22 Nov 2012
- Aldi follows Tesco and Asda with budget tablet
- Court questions Google's API copyright claims
- Microsoft expands encryption over NSA spying "threat"
- Two million passwords uncovered on Pony botnet server
- What's on this week's PC Pro podcast?
- Anger as HP slashes 1,124 UK jobs
- UK Cloud Awards 2014: nominations now open
- Consumer hard drives as reliable as enterprise hardware
- Thinner, reversible USB connectors on the way
- Three offers free roaming in the US
- How to remove SkyDrive from the Windows 8.1 Explorer
- Switching from iPhone to Android? Switch off iMessage
- Why is Google pumping more money into Firefox?
- Sky Broadband Shield review
- Samsung Galaxy S4: how to double your battery life
- Motorola Moto G review: first look
- IBM Watson meets Willy Wonka
- Google’s support policies shove users towards Chrome
- Lenovo Yoga Tablet review: first look
- Michael Dell's reasons to be cheerful
- Securing the Internet of Things
- Internet of Things: five unlikely hacking risks
- Life behind the wall: censorship in China
- 42 best Android apps
- 3D museums that never close
- 29 best Windows 8.1 apps
- Bring an old PC up to speed
- My PC is infected: what now?
- Best smartphones for 2013
- Best printers to buy in 2013
- Windows Phone App Studio: an easy way to create your first Windows Phone 8 app
- The end of Windows XP support: what it really means for businesses
- Don't rely on Chrome's password vault
- Using Buffer to manage your social media
- Microsoft needs its own Steve Jobs
- Forget credit cards: hackers want your Facebook account
- Can't get fast enough broadband? Here's what to do
- Leap Motion and the battle against UI stagnation
- How to build a really bad network
- Facebook Graph Search: don't panic
There are dozens of exciting prizes up for grabs on PC Pro Competitions. All our competitions are free to enter. Try your luck.ENTER NOW