Adobe Premiere Elements 8 review
in Software
Verdict
Still the king of consumer desktop video-editing tools, with some key additions for newcomers but existing users will find fewer reasons to upgrade
Review Date: 25 Sep 2009
Reviewed By: James Morris
Price when reviewed: £63 (£72 inc VAT)
Features & Design
![]()
Value for Money
![]()
Ease of Use
![]()
![]()
Premiere Elements has spent a large part of its existence attempting to escape from its past. It has its origins in the professional package, Premiere Pro, so with each new version Adobe has attempted to balance the underlying power with greater ease of use for the beginner. Adobe Premiere Elements 8 continues this trend, but also includes a few more sophisticated creative options for the seasoned user.
The differences are visible from the first splash screen. There's now an Organize button that leads you to a newly unified asset-management tool. This will be familiar to users of Photoshop Elements 8, but now it's integrated with Premiere Elements.
The Organizer still contains the familiar abilities to retouch photos and create simple image montages. However, it can now import video, plus other video-specific features have been added.
All the options - Organize, Fix, Create and Share - are arranged as a series of tabs along the top of the main window. The first provides facilities for cataloguing and tagging your clips.
You can add your own keywords to group clips from various events together, but performing more detailed tagging yourself across numerous clips would be laborious, so Adobe provides an Auto-Analyzer.
This runs through your media and creates tags automatically, such as overall image quality, whether the footage is shaky, the volume level of the audio, and even the kind of shot. You can then use these to locate the media you're after in the Organize tab - for example, a medium shot to follow a long shot.
Most of the facilities in the Fix tab can only be performed on still images, however, and include automatic correction of colour, levels and red eye, among others. The new Auto Smart Fix also only works on photos within the Organizer. Similarly, the options available under the Create tab are primarily focused on making calendars, greetings cards and collages out of still images.
The Share section includes a couple of specific options for video, allowing you to send video to either mobile devices or the internet. Overall, though, the addition of the Organizer to Premiere Elements feels like a first step rather than a fully mature addition to the video-editing facilities. The video options merely send your clips to Premiere Elements and append them to the end of the current project.
Continuing the ease-of-use theme, the Instant Movie facility added in version 7 has been enhanced with a host of new themes. These group together graphical titles, music, transitions and effects according, then use the smart tags created by the Auto-Analyzer to select the clips with the best quality, and to decide which order to place them in. The results can be a bit random, but for a quick non-narrative edit when you can't be bothered to do it yourself, Instant Movie is potentially useful.
From around the web
64-bit?
I'm guessing that there still isn't a 64-bit build however. This is one of the few applications in the consumer space that would greatly benefit from access to more memory.
I have tried editing projects (in version 7) with about 30 minutes or so of 1080p AVCHD footage and it just grinds to a halt, complains about a lack of memory and then often crashes. Would love to be able to put my 64-bit OS and 8GB ram to use on this, but it needs the software support!
Come Adobe, pull your finger out, you've managed it with Lightroom and CS4.
By shaunb on 25 Sep 2009 ![]()
For shaunb
I have 64 bit - 8GB and can run PE7 for more than one hour and it produces excellent DVD or Blu-Ray disks from 1080p AVCHD footage. I have the PAL version but that should not make a difference. So it is already possible!
By PE7User on 29 Sep 2009 ![]()
For PE7User
Sorry, but running 32-bit software on a 64-bit system is less than optimal. Your 1 hour video processing of AVCHD should be much faster if done using 64-bit software. I agree with shaunb, Adobe are too slow to recognise the benefit to users. I am still lookign for a 64-bit video editing suite.
By leen2 on 1 Oct 2009 ![]()
lost credibility?
A selection of comments from Amazon purchasers, how can this be an A list product?
Good package - shame about the bugs
A lot more work needed
Great software.
The bugs are annoying
Should have been top draw!,
Needs work
Very disappointing
Adobe Element 8 - don't buy if you have windows 7
They won't be wasting my time!
By mattigerbyte1 on 16 Jan 2010 ![]()
No Go
What a disappointment! One simple but in my opinion purely basic and necessary function is not found in PSE8. The ability to print a photo in any size on any position on a sheet of paper. This has been confirmed by Adobe. The recommendation was buying the full PS!
TRY the Incredible Freeware and far better GIMP - http://www.gimp.org/
You'll hate yourself for buying PSE!
By fooUser on 22 May 2010 ![]()
Review in Wrong SECTION
Previous review from me is under Wrong SECTION.I am talking about Photosshop Elements 8 which is also PSE
By fooUser on 22 May 2010 ![]()
Support Issue
I have Premiere Elements 7 (which does work with Win 7 in caase you were wondering) and I have used 8 too.
I have to say it is not worth uprading at all but for one Adobe quirk.
If you do not have the most up-to-date version they will not answer a support question without a £30 fee. If like me you bought v7 just before v8 came out it means you get v poor support and as v8 has now been out for a year v9 is just around the corner so no real incentive to upgrade ....except perhaps to a package that crashes less often.
So maybe I will put the £30 towards Corel videostudio Pro X3
By vegapilot on 16 Jul 2010 ![]()
advertisement
- LinkedIn revenue doubles as membership soars
- Kodak kills off cameras
- UK broadband project spending £1m on legal fees
- Microsoft: Windows on ARM won't be sold separately
- Intel pays five hours of profits to settle antitrust case
- Windows 8 on ARM to run desktop apps... but only Office
- Ofcom dithers over plans to tackle broadband slamming
- Data boost bolsters Vodafone revenue
- Google working on cloud storage system
- Lenovo's profit leaps 54% on market gains
- Chrome's shine getting lost in translation
- BytePac: the cardboard hard disk enclosure
- How tech loosens our grip on reality
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- The ultimate guide to passwords
- How Apple lulls Mac owners into a false sense of security
- Privacy - outdated luxury or public necessity?
- Building the bionic man
- The making of open-source software
- Top 10 stupid security stories of 2011
- 10 techs to watch in 2012
- PC Pro's favourite tech products of 2011
- 10 most read articles on PC Pro in 2011
- 50 ways to make your PC better
- Why virtualisation hasn't slowed the growth of data
- How to make Google AdWords work for your business
- The curse of sloppily written software
- Paying for your crimes with Bitcoin
- Behind the scenes: tech support for Formula 1
- The security risk of fat fingers
- Why Windows Phone 7 isn't quite ready for business
- When will Microsoft stop fiddling with Windows 8?
- Flash down the pan?
- Metro Style apps vs desktop applications
advertisement






