Microsoft Windows Vista review
in Software
Verdict
It's by no means perfect, but the improved security, search and look-and-feel make Vista an obvious upgrade for anyone whose hardware will support it. But only if you can afford the high price.
Review Date: 18 Jan 2007
Reviewed By: Ross Burridge, David Fearon
Price when reviewed: £153 (£176 inc VAT)
Buy it now for: £130
(see more store prices)
Features & Design
![]()
Value for Money
![]()
Ease of Use
![]()
In addition, the x64 edition doesn't allow "unsigned" device drivers to be installed and run - they all need to be approved and digitally certified by Microsoft. Many drivers aren't signed, particularly for low-price hardware, because the certification process costs time and money. For mission-critical servers and workstations, the refusal of x64 to accept unsigned drivers is a good thing, since the majority of unrecoverable OS crashes occur due to errant drivers. But for the average home user, it means that many device drivers for everyday hardware - your low-end but perfectly usable scanner, for instance - will refuse to install on x64.
Networking boost
The networking stack has had a massive overhaul, principally to improve security and reliability. It's also introduced native support for Internet Protocol 6, important for the future, but of limited use right now.
The new Network and Sharing Center handily gathers together most of the common settings, and should make less technical users more comfortable. Connecting to a new wired or wireless network is much simpler, with informative dialogs quickly guiding you through the process.
The new Windows Meeting Space application is a kind of wireless ad hoc virtual-conferencing application, allowing participants to share documents as "handouts", see each other's Desktop, and even assume control of another participant's system if the need arises. The idea isn't to provide a remote teleconferencing system but for a supplemental, shared resource to augment physical meetings and reduce the need to swap USB sticks at the end of presentations. Meeting Space is included in all versions of Vista, but Home Basic only allows you to join existing meetings, not organise them.
Power management and mobile features
Power management has received a major overhaul. For a start, advanced power settings now give greater granularity, so you can tweak everything from wireless adapter settings to maximum processor states. Both AMD's Cool'n'Quiet and Intel Enhanced SpeedStep should work without extra drivers too.
The power-saving states of Windows XP (Standby and Hibernate) have nominally been merged into one Sleep state. By default, desktop PCs will go into a standby state after 20 minutes. Notebooks will initially go into this state, but if they're unused for longer, they'll go into Hibernate to save more power.
With luck, the company that you're buying your Vista PC from will have tested all this. However, if you're installing Vista yourself, there's no guarantee that all your hardware will play nicely when it comes to flipping through these power states. Expect to do some manual adjustment.
Another oddity is that the default "off" button in the Start menu is actually mapped to Sleep, which may cause some confusion. (If you're interested in the history, visit www.pcpro.co.uk/links/149_vista3.)
Power management isn't the only enhancement for notebook users. Commonly used mobile settings are grouped together in the new Mobility Center, including sound, power management and, where supported, screen brightness. There's also a Presentation mode that allows you to change a number of settings in a single hit - switch to a more professional Desktop backdrop and lower resolution to suit a projector, for example.
One notable change for users of Windows Mobile devices is that ActiveSync isn't compatible with Windows Vista. Instead, there's the Mobile Device Center - not actually included in the default installation, but available to download in a beta form. It will also be pushed out via Windows Update when finished. Even now, it's a big improvement over ActiveSync, offering clearer support for importing pictures and other data from mobile devices. It also copes with multiple devices more effectively.
Best Prices
Price comparison powered by 
| Prices, delivery and availability at 1 retailer | Go | |
|
£130 | Go |
From around the web
advertisement
- LinkedIn revenue doubles as membership soars
- Kodak kills off cameras
- UK broadband project spending £1m on legal fees
- Microsoft: Windows on ARM won't be sold separately
- Intel pays five hours of profits to settle antitrust case
- Windows 8 on ARM to run desktop apps... but only Office
- Ofcom dithers over plans to tackle broadband slamming
- Data boost bolsters Vodafone revenue
- Google working on cloud storage system
- Lenovo's profit leaps 54% on market gains
- Chrome's shine getting lost in translation
- BytePac: the cardboard hard disk enclosure
- How tech loosens our grip on reality
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- The ultimate guide to passwords
- How Apple lulls Mac owners into a false sense of security
- Privacy - outdated luxury or public necessity?
- Building the bionic man
- The making of open-source software
- Top 10 stupid security stories of 2011
- 10 techs to watch in 2012
- PC Pro's favourite tech products of 2011
- 10 most read articles on PC Pro in 2011
- 50 ways to make your PC better
- Why virtualisation hasn't slowed the growth of data
- How to make Google AdWords work for your business
- The curse of sloppily written software
- Paying for your crimes with Bitcoin
- Behind the scenes: tech support for Formula 1
- The security risk of fat fingers
- Why Windows Phone 7 isn't quite ready for business
- When will Microsoft stop fiddling with Windows 8?
- Flash down the pan?
- Metro Style apps vs desktop applications
advertisement






