Microsoft Windows Vista review

Instant Search

Windows XP's search feature was painfully slow and cumbersome, and although both Windows 2000 and XP had indexing services, they were turned off by default. That's all changed in Vista, with an index acting as its principle source for search results. All Explorer windows (and many of the integrated apps) contain a search box at the top right, and results appear almost as soon as you start typing. Once you train Vista to your way of working (by adding extra folders to the index or including non-indexed locations and system files), it's much, much quicker than XP - and there isn't a bounding puppy in sight, either.

There's also an Instant Search box integrated into the redesigned Start menu. With the focus switching to it immediately, hit the Windows key and type in part of the application name - "calc", for example - and the standard program list is replaced by search results. Applications are prioritised (in this case showing Calculator uppermost), with emails or documents displayed beneath. For browsing programs, the All Programs link now uses scrollbars to display large numbers of items, rather than XP's cascading approach. The end result is both neater and quicker to use.

User folders

All the patronising "My" prefixes have been dropped from user folders, replaced with the concept of User and Public files. There's also been an overdue rearrangement of the default hierarchy: the user's "Home" folder, named after your user account, contains Documents, Music, Pictures and Videos folders, as well as per-user Desktop and Favorites folders. New to Vista are Downloads, Contacts (holding .contact files), Links (with the shortcuts used in the Favorite Links pane), Searches (for Saved Searches) and Saved Games. It's a welcome attempt to rationalise things, and makes previously hidden-away data more accessible for transferring or backing up - assuming that applications take advantage of the new structure.

Each one of these "special" folders is location-independent, with a Properties tab allowing you to move them elsewhere, either locally or on a network. It's a great feature, but not very robust: you can't move the root user directory, for example, which would have been a great way of rapidly setting up an OS-independent file store. It's also easily confused, and can end up losing the links altogether if you're not careful. Worst of all, using network locations invokes Vista's Sync Center to try to keep a copy available for offline use (not helpful for a music server, for example), and it can easily all get rather complicated. It should be friendlier than this.

Sidebar and Gadgets

The Windows Sidebar has been something of a motif for Vista since the early days of Longhorn. Its final implementation is comparatively modest, acting as a docking bar for Gadgets - small, generally single-purpose applications that can also be free-floating on the Desktop. Some Gadgets come pre-installed, with the more functional including a clock, weather information, a picture frame and Post-It-style notepad.

Sidebar is enabled by default and, providing they have enough Desktop space, we're sure most people will keep it active. The RSS reader is particularly useful and, while the clock and weather Gadgets are hardly revolutionary, they're both worth keeping.

At launch, however, Sidebar was a little buggy. The RSS feeder didn't update automatically on one of our sample PCs, while the whole Sidebar proved to be a memory hog on another.