T-Mobile G1 review
in Smartphones
Verdict
Android looks promising, albeit with kinks to iron out, but we remain unconvinced by the practical but clunky hardware.
Review Date: 5 Nov 2008
Reviewed By: Jonathan Bray
Price when reviewed: Free
Features & Design
![]()
Value for Money
![]()
Ease of Use
![]()
The most intensely anticipated phone this year has finally arrived. It's T-Mobile's G1, sporting Google's brand spanking new open-source Android operating system, and it's the most interesting development in mobile phones since the appearance of the first iPhone a year ago.
The Android interface
First impressions are good. When you first take the G1 out of the box and turn it on, you'll have it set up and synchronised with your Gmail email, contacts and calendar in just a minute or two. It's so incredibly straightforward even a novice could do it. Emails are pushed to the phone by default, so you're alerted as they arrive.
This simplicity extends to the rest of the interface. Commonly-used shortcuts, a clock and 'widgets' feature prominently on the customisable home screen, while other applications are a mere finger drag away. As with the iPhone, icons can be placed not only on the main home screen but also a pair of supplementary ones to the left and right. Simply sweep your finger across the screen to the left or right to get access these.
At the top of the screen is the always-present notifications bar. A bit like Windows Mobile, this is where the battery life indicator sits, the signal strength bars and also other notifications such as downloads. In a neat touch, you can 'pull' this down for more information, too.
At the bottom is a pull-up menu with all the phone's programs on it - they're organised in a simple grid that can be dragged up and down with a finger - while hitting the G1's menu button just below the screen pops up a menu offering context-sensitive options.
Just browsing
Browsing the web is a joyously intuitive process and the onboard web browser works extremely well, rendering all the websites we visited accurately, reliably and quickly. Navigating around pages is simple - just drag your finger to pan or use the device's trackball to flick between links on a page. The latter is surprisingly nippy and intuitive.
Despite the 480 x 320 resolution, the screen feels cramped, which means you have to do a fair bit of zooming in and out, which isn't ideal, and the zoom tools aren't brilliant - you have to tap an icon at the bottom of the screen to get up close or zoom out. It's nowhere near as good as Opera Mobile 9.5's double tap to zoom or the iPhone's pinch gestures. There's a handy magnifying glass tool that allows you to read text and headlines while zoomed right back from the page, but it still can't quite match its main rivals.
Other annoyances include an inability to select text in the address bar, which means copying and pasting URLs is a pain, and a refusal to download some file types. We tried to download a Librivox audio book recording - just an MP3 file - and were informed, rather unhelpfully, that the download had simply failed.
Simple email works well. You get push with Gmail, plus standard scheduled retrieval for third party POP3 and IMAP accounts. It's best to use the G1 with the former, however; this preserves all the cool features of Gmail, from threaded conversations, through labels and stars, to the powerful search utility.
The contacts tool works just as neatly - our test account had well over 500 entries in it and we were able to navigate from top to bottom of this list with one sweep of the finger.
Again, though, there are some minor irritations. Switch to the dialler screen and start tapping away on the numeric pad and, unlike the Windows Mobile phones here and the BlackBerry handsets, suggested contacts don't appear as you type.
From around the web
advertisement
- Google legal chief: privacy laws too hard on SMBs
- No free Visual Studio for Windows 8 desktop developers
- Facebook spends $1bn on Instagram... then launches its own Camera app
- Who sends Google the most takedown notices? Microsoft
- Microsoft wins text patent battle against Motorola
- Watchdog fines firm £50,000 over Android malware
- Intel to test smartcity future on London
- June decision on Microsoft's billion-dollar EU fine
- Yahoo browser launch marred by security flaw
- Autonomy management walk out over HP bureaucracy
- Laptop bag reviews: nine tested
- Sony VAIO T Series Ultrabook review: first look
- Revealed: the military standards and robots HP uses to test its laptops
- Windows 8: multi-monitors and double standards?
- Why is TalkTalk's year-old porn filter suddenly big news?
- Why are laptop screens so far behind mobiles?
- HP EliteBook Folio review: first look
- The shoebox-sized all-in-one printer
- Forget the Ultrabook: here comes the HP Sleekbook
- HP Spectre XT review: first look
- Can you buy technology with a clean conscience?
- The death of email
- How to use Windows 8 Metro
- 30 best features of Windows 8
- How to become a cyberspy
- Create your own smart home
- Install a custom ROM on your smartphone
- Can the Raspberry Pi save computing?
- Google: the pirates' best friend?
- Backups: ten tips to keep your data safe
- Why you have to be left in the dark on OS patches
- Is Microsoft mismanaging Windows on ARM?
- Dealing with spam surrogates
- Why 3G broadband can be better and cheaper than ADSL
- Is Twitter bad for business?
- Publishing your email address isn't a security disaster
- Why you'll need a fax machine to develop iOS apps
- Learning to adapt to the mobile web
- Why you shouldn't use WPS on your Wi-Fi network
- Disabled users suffer when software breaks the rules
advertisement





