Apple Mac mini with Snow Leopard Server (2nd gen) review
in Servers
Verdict
It's undeniably expensive, but in return you get a beautifully compact package and a fine operating system
Review Date: 11 Oct 2010
Reviewed By: Steve Cassidy
Price when reviewed: £791 (£929 inc VAT)
Features & Design
![]()
Value for Money
![]()
Performance
![]()
The new Mac mini has a cousin - a server version, shorn of the DVD drive but with a second hard disk on the inside of that improbably tiny, but surprisingly heavy, alloy case. This model follows on from the server version of the old form-factor Mac mini.
The obvious question, then as now, is why buy a Mac server when it's so easy and much cheaper to assemble a pile of PC components to do the same job? The mini won't persuade everyone, but it brings a good few features that lend it appeal.
The first is the sheer density of computing power. Around ten of the old Mac minis fitted into the footprint of one 1U server, and the new version makes it even easier to pack them into a tight space: it has no separate power supply brick, nor DVD drive, and it can run sitting flat or on one edge. The included SD slot can take a 32GB card, and is bootable (although Apple would prefer you didn't use that as an everyday system drive - "for emergencies" is how the company put it to us).
You can use the two 500GB internal laptop-type hard drives as a plain pair of disks, or a mirror, or a stripe. Apple claims that lots of users of the preceding model didn't opt for an old-school RAID configuration, but instead used Time Machine to back up the boot disk to the secondary disk.
By rights, a platform such as this - whether you use OS X Server or find a way to put something else on the machine - should help to completely redefine a whole chunk of the market. Look around at the rackmount boxes running in your server room and ask if there's any job they do that wouldn't fit in a Mac mini server. While a 2.66GHz Core 2 Duo is no match for Intel's latest Xeons when it comes to sheer processing muscle, and 4GB of plain DDR3 RAM seems positively miserly, it's more than enough computing power to run services such as wikis, mail servers and web servers for a 25-strong team (depending, as ever, on usage).
The other benefit of the Mac mini is that it runs on about a tenth the watts in a twentieth of the physical space of a conventional rack: we measured 11W in idle and 85W when thrashed. Despite the mains transformer being inside the alloy box, and it being the height of summer, the plume of warmish air emanating from the mini's rear never became distressed. This is in stark contrast to the old Mac mini, which can be readily found in a rack "manually" by the hot squirt of air.
From around the web
"It's undeniably expensive"
I think you've found its main flaw.
By Lacrobat on 13 Oct 2010 ![]()
Price up a windows server!
Hardware £?????
Windows Server 2008 R2 (inc 5 cal) - £1022.58 (Amazon)
and that's just for 5 users. Depending on how many users use this server, it could cost you thousands more just in licenses.
Doesn't seem quite so expensive now.
By btrewern on 13 Oct 2010 ![]()
Can't agree with calling it expensive
Sure, if all you want is a file and printer server then you can get one cheaper from the likes of Dell but as btrewern has already stated, if you add Small Business Server the price jumps up to £1450 and that's only for 5 clients. For 10-30 or so people the Mac Mini has to look tempting considering all the functionality you get for free with the server OS.
By justanotheruser on 13 Oct 2010 ![]()
Windows isn't the only server OS, though, on PC hardware. Personally, I don't se expensive as that much of a drawback - once you're up to 25 users, after all, the cost-per-user gets pretty close to the user's annual electricity bill for computing...
By Steve_Cassidy on 13 Oct 2010 ![]()
PCPRO should compare Server software expenses.
Perhaps PC PRO should do a comparison of the features, capabilities and user friendliness you get with the different server packages that are available on low end machines serving a small business. Also do a cost analysis for say for 5/10/50 people on various systems including Linux). If you did that I think PCPro would find the Mac Mini is not that expensive, at least compared to Microsoft solutions.
Also, if anyone could simplify Microsoft's server options that would be great as well! ;-)
By martinws on 14 Oct 2010 ![]()
Equivalent (non-Apple) hardware?
Question: what is an equivalent form factor PC (ideally off the shelf) that could run linux or win for a home network with a mix of macs, pcs, linux and phones? Predominantly for shared drive access for photos / vids etc.
Must be silent and v low power / heat so it can live in the lounge
By aitch2000 on 23 Oct 2010 ![]()
advertisement
- Autonomy's Lynch joins 27,000 on way out of HP
- ICO: no fines for breaking cookie rules
- HP set to slash up to 30,000 jobs
- Government sites to miss cookie deadline
- Microsoft tweaks multi-monitor support in Windows 8
- Apple patches Leopard, despite ending support last year
- Defra opens rural broadband funding applications
- BT's broadband sales surpass calls revenue
- Apple patches multiple security issues
- FBI warns travellers to beware attacks via hotel Wi-Fi
- Laptop bag reviews: nine tested
- Sony VAIO T Series Ultrabook review: first look
- Revealed: the military standards and robots HP uses to test its laptops
- Windows 8: multi-monitors and double standards?
- Why is TalkTalk's year-old porn filter suddenly big news?
- Why are laptop screens so far behind mobiles?
- HP EliteBook Folio review: first look
- The shoebox-sized all-in-one printer
- Forget the Ultrabook: here comes the HP Sleekbook
- HP Spectre XT review: first look
- The death of email
- Backups: ten tips to keep your data safe
- Tablets for work: the best apps, kit and advice
- Why everyone hates the IT department
- Is online shopping security fundamentally broken?
- New cookie laws: why website owners should be worried
- Are work web blockers a waste of time?
- 11 golden rules for virtualisation
- When is it right to go public with security flaws?
- Is your business ready for VoIP?
- Why you have to be left in the dark on OS patches
- Is Microsoft mismanaging Windows on ARM?
- Dealing with spam surrogates
- Why 3G broadband can be better and cheaper than ADSL
- Is Twitter bad for business?
- Publishing your email address isn't a security disaster
- Why you'll need a fax machine to develop iOS apps
- Learning to adapt to the mobile web
- Why you shouldn't use WPS on your Wi-Fi network
- Disabled users suffer when software breaks the rules
advertisement






