Skip to navigation

eSoft InstaGate 404s review

eSoft InstaGate 404s

Verdict

Strong web content security measures, but it's pricey and easily overtaxed

Review Date: 5 Dec 2012

Reviewed By: Dave Mitchell

Price when reviewed: £570 (£684 inc VAT)

Overall Rating
3 stars out of 6

Features & Design
4 stars out of 6

Value for Money
3 stars out of 6

Performance
3 stars out of 6

The InstaGate 404s appliance from US company eSoft targets the SoHo market and offers tough web security for networks of up to 15 users. The base system provides an SPI firewall and VPN support, while eSoft’s Web ThreatPak adds IPS, web content filtering, gateway antivirus and anti-spyware, plus IM and P2P app controls.

It’s a compact appliance with four Fast Ethernet ports providing WAN, dual-switched LAN and DMZ duties, and would seem to be the ideal candidate for use in a small office. However, the 1GHz VIA C7 processor’s cooling fan is noisy: it will be hard to ignore in cramped environments.

Installation is a smooth process: a wizard helps with registration and the Web ThreatPak download and, once active, it keeps all scanners and signatures updated automatically. The firewall has predefined rules so you’re ready to go, but you can add your own if you want more control over specific services.

Options are provided for creating site-to-site IPsec VPNs with other InstaGates or client VPNs for mobile workers. For web content filtering, you can swiftly set up HTTP scanning using the transparent proxy mode. Policies can either be applied to all users or selectively to networks defined by their IP address ranges.

eSoft InstaGate 404s

Proxy authentication comes into play with the user mode, where you can employ the appliance’s local database or an Active Directory server. Unlike most competing products, content filtering is carried out locally and not in the cloud, so eSoft’s own URL database needs to be downloaded to the appliance.

This didn’t take long and we were then able to create blocking policies using any of the 17 URL categories and more than 50 sub-categories. You can leave policies permanently active or apply a schedule so they’re active only on selected days and times.

Gateway antivirus is enabled with a single click, and you can create lists of IP addresses that are exempt from scanning. Anti-spyware is just as easy to activate, and for IPS you can add details of specific servers you want protected, where the appliance will then create custom profiles.

eSoft claims a firewall performance of 100Mbits/sec, although in reality, this is the throughput limit of the WAN port. To test this, we hooked up the 404s to the lab’s Ixia XM2 chassis and its Xcellon-Ultra NP load modules. The Ixia IxLoad app confirmed the firewall was good for around 90Mbits/sec, which dropped only slightly with all UTM functions activated. However, using the appliance’s web interface during testing had a big impact on performance.

As we refreshed the ThreatMonitor interface, we saw IxLoad register a significant drop in performance, with throughput falling as low as 10Mbits/sec for brief periods. With such a small supported userbase we don’t see this as a serious problem, but if you have bandwidth-hungry users you’ll have to avoid using the web console where possible.

There’s no denying that the web content security features of the InstaGate 404s are highly accomplished, but there are serious issues. The noisy operation dampens its appeal for the smaller office, and our tests show that it’s operating at the limits of its performance. The price is the final stumbling block: stack it up against the PC Pro Recommended WatchGuard XTM 25-W and it really isn’t such good value for money.

Author: Dave Mitchell

Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here
Be the first to comment this article

You need to Login or Register to comment.

(optional)

Latest Security appliances Reviews
Netgear ProSecure UTM25S review

Netgear ProSecure UTM25S

Category: Security appliances
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £959
Cyberoam CR35iNG review

Cyberoam CR35iNG

Category: Security appliances
Rating: 6 out of 6
Price: £1,698
WatchGuard XTM 515 review

WatchGuard XTM 515

Category: Security appliances
Rating: 6 out of 6
Price: £1,213
ExactTrak Security Guardian review

ExactTrak Security Guardian

Category: Security appliances
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £354
WatchGuard XTM 330 review

WatchGuard XTM 330

Category: Security appliances
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £1,012
Compare reviews: Security appliances

advertisement

Latest News Stories Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Features
Latest Real World Computing

advertisement

Sponsored Links
 

 
SEARCH
Loading
WEB ID
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010
 
 

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.