Leap Motion Controller review
An appallingly inaccurate gesture controller that makes us want to throw our hands up in the air, not towards the PC
Review Date: 14 Aug 2013
Reviewed By: Barry Collins
Price when reviewed: £58 (£70 inc VAT)
Features & Design
Value for Money
The mistake most people make when first using a Leap Motion is to try and use the screen as a touch screen, moving your entire hand to where you want to go. If you instead use it where you keep your hand within a roughly 30cm box over the controller and point to where you want to navigate it suddenly becomes much easier to use and control apps and Windows itself. I think this review is unnecessarily harsh, perhaps the reviewer should try again but this time use it as I've suggested above, I think you'll be surprised how much more intuitive it suddenly becomes.
By skarlock on 15 Aug 2013
The controller should have been places just in front of the keyboard and the lights are bright.
And the guys reviewing it, seriously? They look like they could hardly operate a coffee machine let alone something that requires spacial intuitive motion recognition.
This was a KicKstarter project which means it takes time to develop and raise funds. I find it offensive that they could make a negative quip or swipe at the process without explanation?
The Leap Motion device is not perfect but the process will result in a great device. It needs work and with many people now using, testing, pushing the limits and developing the device is well on its way to success.
But this review was poorly executed, poorly researched and terribly presented.
By BuddMargolis on 15 Aug 2013
We tried the controller in a variety of positions (not only those shown in the brief video), on both desktop and laptops, and the experience didn't improve.
Likewise, we tried a variety of control methods, from the gentle, controlled motions @Skarlock recommends, to full sweeps. None provided a satisfactory experience.
At least three of us in the office tried the device, so our experience isn't based on the prejudices of one reviewer.
By Barry_Collins on 15 Aug 2013
Certainly not prejudice
Well, doing a quick Google of other reviews for the product, it would suggest that pretty much everyone is prejudiced against it.
I'm also not sure why pointing out its Kickstart credentials should make it any better a product? I don't get the "many people now using, testing, pushing the limits and developing the device". They are not selling this as a beta device for developers but as a finished end product for consumers.
By DArtiss on 15 Aug 2013
Yes, it is possible
Yes, it is possible to control your computer with this. It's also possible to play a scale on a piano with a rubber hand on the end of a fishing rod. Maybe the software will improve.
By kennapier on 15 Aug 2013
Glad to hear there is something worse than trying to operate Windows on a touch screen.
By milliganp on 15 Aug 2013
"doing a quick Google of other reviews for the product, it would suggest that pretty much everyone is prejudiced against it."
Prejudiced means biased, bigoted. Usually when a product receives universally bad reviews it means just one thing - that the product is crap.
By PaulOckenden on 16 Aug 2013
A solution in search of a problem?
A product who's time has not yet come, or to parrot Oscar Wilde on America "It will be great when they finish it".
Could we now get a review of Personify, another product where the website implies a lot more than it seems to do?
By milliganp on 16 Aug 2013
My experience was that installation didn't work from an ordinary user account. Uninstalling and reinstalling using an administrator account worked.
Still no proper XP support though.
There was also excessive processor utilization.
By tirons1 on 19 Aug 2013
Google Earth unusable
I ordered one last year and got it on day one. The sensor is very fussy and complains about the wrong light levels. Google earth takes on a new, infuriating dimension by spinning more than an MP at full tilt and the touch screen interface for Windows never starts up.
It might have been a kickstarter project but I think it is a year ahead of its time and especially with the Windows Kinect officially MIA, I would leave touch screens to tablets (look at Apple!)
By mark_scott_mcse on 23 Aug 2013
- Cook: Microsoft should have released Office for iPad sooner
- What's on this week's PC Pro podcast?
- Universal wireless charging gets a boost from Microsoft
- Amazon Phone: release date, features and 3D display
- Apple offers sneak peak at OS X via Beta Seed
- American grip on web loosens ahead of key net meeting
- Apple fixes security flaw, fingerprint scanner with iOS 7.1.1
- Heartbleed: LibreSSL scrubs "irresponsible" OpenSSL code
- Windows Cloud: should Microsoft mimic Chrome OS?
- Lytro unveils its next light-field camera: the $1,599 Illum
- Hello Cortana, it's nice to meet you
- Windows 8.1 Update: an abject surrender
- The insane economics of Sky Now TV
- No such thing as a free app... so pay up if you want quality
- Time to outlaw crapware-laden installers
- Windows Phone 8.1 video: hands-on
- Office for iPad: key information
- Why every PC buyer owes Richard Durkin a debt of gratitude
- HTC One M8 vs Samsung Galaxy S5: 2014's big-hitters compared
- Windows XP end of life: key information
- How to upgrade from Windows XP to Ubuntu
- The great iPhone ripoff and how it works
- Heartbleed: what you need to know and do
- Data recovery: inside the clean room
- Best tablet PCs to buy in 2014
- How much RAM do you really need?
- News of the weird: the strangest ever tech stories
- Five hyped technologies: disruptive or not?
- Piracy's dying: why we're all going straight
- Office: should you buy it, rent it - or dump it?
- Why laptops with serial ports matter to the Internet of Things
- Make your mobile battery last longer
- Small steps into handling Big Data
- Nexus 5: does it really run stock Android?
- How to get broadband to a garden office
- How to write your company's IT security policy
- Raspberry Pi and Wolfram: a must-have for every child
- Could you get by with Office Web Apps?
- The best Android antivirus apps for 2014
- Headings vs headers: how to use both in Word