Skip to navigation

Philips E-line 237E3QPHSU review

Philips E-Line 237E3QPHSU

Verdict

A bargain price for a 23in IPS monitor, but poor backlighting undermines its appeal

Review Date: 31 Jan 2012

Reviewed By: Sasha Muller

Price when reviewed: £125 (£150 inc VAT)

Overall Rating
3 stars out of 6

Features & Design
4 stars out of 6

Value for Money
3 stars out of 6

Image Quality
3 stars out of 6

It isn’t often at PC Pro that we become excited about a budget monitor. Unless, that is, the monitor in question manages to pack in an IPS panel for less than £200. Philips’ snazzily named 237E3QPHSU does just that, packing in a Full HD IPS panel and LED backlighting at an unusually affordable price.

Given the budget, it’s nice to see that Philips has made an effort with the styling. A strip of blue transparent plastic runs around the monitor’s edge and a hidden LED gently lights up a lip of blue beneath the Philips logo. It makes for a very attractive monitor. Get up close, however, and the construction is a little plastic. The stand wobbles to and fro at the slightest provocation, and adjustment is limited to a few degrees of forwards and backwards tilt.

Still, there are plenty of features here. Philips has managed to squeeze an internal power supply into the Philips’ slender frame, and the single D-SUB socket is accompanied by two HDMI inputs. There’s also a presence sensor, which dims the backlight and subsequently turns off the display if you’re away from your desk for any length of time.

This monitor is all about the panel, however. IPS technology delivers more vivid colour reproduction, and wider viewing angles with less off-axis colour shift than the TN-based monitors typically found at this price point.

Initially, the Philips doesn’t disappoint. Viewing angles aren’t quite as wide as pricier models, but they’re still wide enough and, aside from a slight bluish tint to whites, colours and skin tones look natural. Don’t install the supplied monitor driver, however; inexplicably, doing so ruins the colour accuracy.

Philips E-Line 237E3QPHSU

Without the driver, the budget Philips achieves some great figures. Colour accuracy fares particularly well, with an average Delta E of 3.1 and a maximum deviation of 6.3 in the greens and blues. For a budget monitor, this is rather impressive.

Further examination reveals some flaws. The colour temperature of 7,227k explains the bluish tint, and while the supplied SmartResponse software makes it possible to get closer to 6,500k (there are adjustments for colour temperature, black point, contrast and brightness controls, as well as small onscreen images for guiding any adjustments), we found any amount of fine-tuning caused colour accuracy to suffer negatively as a result.

Worse still, the LED backlighting doesn’t only exhibit leakage around the panel’s edges, but it also fails to deliver much in the way of brightness. Even with the brightness control set to maximum it reaches a luminance of only 184cd/m2; unusually dim, even by budget standards. Upping the contrast to 60 improves matters, the brightness nudging upwards to 226cd/m2, but even this does little for the Philips’ poor contrast. The low brightness and greyish blacks conspire to produce a contrast ratio of only 448:1; the stark monochromatic opening scenes of Black Swan looked unusually washed out and are lacking in detail. After a strong start, it’s a disappointing finale.

On paper, the E-line 237E3QPHSU looks like an absolute bargain. Unfortunately, despite the appealing price, its flaws are too serious to forgive. With ViewSonic’s VP2365-LED delivering an adjustable stand and far better image quality for £50 more, those in the market for an affordable IPS display would be wise to set their sights, and their budget, a little higher.

Author: Sasha Muller

Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here
User comments

And it's a poor aspect ratio too

As well as the average image quality, it also has the flaw of only being a 16:9 monitor as well. For a 23" monitor, that's only 11 inches of height. My old 19" 4:3 screen manages 12" of height!

Hence "upgrading" from a 19" screen to a 23" screen like this actually gives less vertical screen space.

Not good.

By Trippynet on 1 Feb 2012

Poor Aspect? Poor measurement

Trippynet, if your monitor has a screen height of 12" then it has actually a 20" diagonal. 4:3 is a 3-4-5 triangle making diagonal:height 5:3. 16:9 isn't so nice but diagonal:height is 2.04:1.

Hence a 23" 16:9 is 11.27451" high and a 19" 4:3 is 11.4" high - near enough the same.

Still a good point; for viewing pleasure a 23" monitor is the widescreen replacement for a 19". Using the diagonal measurement is a sales ploy to get bigger numbers to compare. Using just height is a better comparison for resolution etc. while being aspect ratio independant.

By tonyyates on 4 Feb 2012

Old 19"

Actually both of you got it partially wrong, old 19"s aren't 4:3, but 5:4, so they are almost square, 11.9" high. :)

By storm311 on 4 Apr 2012

Leave a comment

You need to Login or Register to comment.

(optional)

Latest Monitors Reviews
Acer K272HUL review

Acer K272HUL

Category: Monitors
Rating: 4 out of 6
Price: £364
AOC q2770Pqu review

AOC q2770Pqu

Category: Monitors
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £360
NEC MultiSync EA244UHD review

NEC MultiSync EA244UHD

Category: Monitors
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £1,295
NEC MultiSync PA272W review

NEC MultiSync PA272W

Category: Monitors
Rating: 5 out of 6
Price: £984
Eizo ColorEdge CG277 review

Eizo ColorEdge CG277

Category: Monitors
Rating: 6 out of 6
Price: £1,559
Compare reviews: Monitors

advertisement

Latest News Stories Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Features
Latest Real World Computing

advertisement

Sponsored Links
 

 
SEARCH
Loading
WEB ID
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010
 
 

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.