MPs: laws on GCHQ snooping "completely useless"
By Shona Ghosh
Posted on 28 Jun 2013 at 09:19
Revelations of mass snooping programs from GCHQ and the US National Security Agency have shown up the UK’s laws governing surveillance as totally ineffective, MPs have said.
Conservative MP David Davis and Labour deputy chair Tom Watson said Prism, and its UK counterpart Tempora, had highlighted that parliamentary supervision over surveillance was "completely useless".
"Our supervision procedures are completely useless, not just weak as we thought," said Davis, speaking at an Open Rights Group meeting chaired by Watson. "Let’s say the foreign secretary signs this off. It then comes up in the House of Commons – what does he say? That we never comment on security matters. There’s no accountability to Parliament."
Our supervision procedures are completely useless, not just weak as we thought
Although GCHQ is accountable to the Intelligence Security Committee (ISC), Davis pointed out that it reports directly to the prime minister, not Parliament, meaning surveillance operations are never openly debated.
"What Tempora has done in political terms is throw up a really big red flag saying actually we have to rethink completely from scratch about all the oversight arrangements we have," he said.
Tempora is thought to be GCHQ's extensive cable-tapping operation, with the agency allegedly scooping up huge amounts of communications data, including the content of phone calls and emails.
Davis and security experts at the meeting said it was time to rethink the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, which is supposed to govern the interception of communications such as Tempora.
"There’s a provision in the legislation which says the act is essentially voluntary code, and you don’t have to follow it anyway. That’s its practical effect, I'm afraid," said solicitor advocate Simon McKay.
No snooper’s charter
Both MPs also dismissed the return of the "snooper’s charter", despite renewed interest in the communications data bill after the recent Woolwich murder.
They said the disclosures around Tempora meant the bill was unlikely to become legislation in the next year.
Theresa May had been using the Woolwich murder to try and revive interest in the bill, arguing that it was "essential" to security services, despite opposition from M15.
But Davis and Watson said more MPs were increasingly sceptical about the bill after the surveillance scandal. Davis also called on the European commission to keep up the pressure on the foreign secretary, after EU commissioner Vivane Reding asked William Hague for details about Tempora.
Is your business a social business? For helpful info and tips visit our hub.
Now there is a surprise !
By rhobstein3 on 29 Jun 2013
Because MPs are out of touch with the real world but try to control it
By invalidscreenname on 25 Jul 2013
If you're concerned / outraged by GCHQ's Tempora programme then sign this petition calling for a Public Inquiry.
By DarkDoc on 25 Jul 2013
- 20 years of PC Pro: our best covers
- Why we've closed the PC Pro forums
- How to turn off Google Location Tracking
- 20 years of PC Pro: our greatest review mistakes
- 20 years of PC Pro: our first A-List
- Wikipedia's "right to be forgotten" protest hits the wrong note
- 3D printing hits the high street for plastic selfies
- 20 years of PC Pro: What amazed us in our first issue
- How Google Glass ruined my lunch hour
- Smartphone battery packs: can a USB power pack beat the festival battery blues?
- How to write your company's IT security policy
- The key to choosing a secure password
- Please stop reposting fake Facebook messages
- Is Facebook safe for business?
- Don't rely on Chrome's password vault
- Facebook Graph Search: don't panic
- Gmail drafts and Pastebin: could they evade the email snoops?
- Applying for a job at GCHQ? Here's your plain-text password
- Google two-step verification: a must for business email
- Yes, I write down my passwords