Skip to navigation
Latest News

Google's Schmidt: China a "menace" to online security


By Stewart Mitchell

Posted on 4 Feb 2013 at 11:57

Google's Eric Schmidt has launched a scathing attack on China, describing the country as a "menace" to the web.

In a preview of an upcoming book­ by Google's executive chairman, the Wall Street Journal unveiled a slew of criticisms against China, noting the prevalence and apparent acceptance of industrial espionage.

Google and China have clashed often in the past over web censorship, and Schmidt has branded the country as "the world’s most active and enthusiastic filterer of information".

According to Schmidt, western countries and companies are at a severe disadvantage because Chinese rivals are stealing their information, with little deterrent from China's authorities.

"The disparity between American and Chinese firms and their tactics will put both the government and the companies of the United States as a distinct disadvantage," Schmidt and his co-writer Jared Cohen said.

the United States will not take the same path of digital corporate espionage, as its laws are much stricter (and better enforced)

That's because "the United States will not take the same path of digital corporate espionage, as its laws are much stricter (and better enforced) and because illicit competition violates the American sense of fair play," they claim.

Schmidt also believes the lack of trust in China - typified by Chinese communication company Huawei facing accusations it could place backdoors in networks - could lead to more problems.

China's growing importance as a technology supplier will mean companies in other countries will need to increasingly align themselves with the government to guard against other countries mis-using their technologies," he said.

"There will come a time when their commercial and national interests align and contrast with China — say, over the abuse of their products by an authoritarian state — and they will coordinate their efforts with their governments on both diplomatic and technical levels," Schmidt says in the book, The New Digital Age.

Split in the web

The increasingly bitter war of words between officials in the US and China - and companies from both countries - could even lead to a split in the web, Schmidt believes, with separate forks built around different technologies used by countries with similar political ideologies.

Countries with freedom of speech laws and more open web rules could align themselves with a web based on Western attitudes and protocols, with other countries taking a more authoritarian approach.

"In the future, superpower supplier nations will look to create their spheres of online influence around specific protocols and products, so that their technologies form the backbone of a particular society and their client states come to rely on certain critical infrastructure that the superpower alone builds, services and controls," Schmidt wrote.

Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here
User comments

If you sup with the devil....

The sight of Mr Schmidt hand-wringing about 'democracy' whilst at the helm of a huge, manipulative multinational behemoth is pretty laughable. But what he says still carries a grain of truth.

The first thing is to strip-out any notions of 'democracy' and\or individual 'liberty' from Mr Schmidt's world-view.
Capitalism always tends towards monopoly, and Google exemplifies this to a tee. There is nothing even loosely democratic about monopolies.
Similarly the notion of the 'individual' being implicitly espoused isn't you or I, but people like Mr Schmidt.

China is a rather nasty place run by greedy self-seeking 'individuals' not unlike Mr Schmidt. China does appear to break many of the 'rules' of International Trade & Capitalism, but the reality is that there is only one Rule: "Win at all costs".
All the rest is just hot air & Window-dressing.

China, under its current leadership simply follows that cardinal rule without bothering with the PR & pretence which surrounds 'proper' Western Capitalism, as exemplified by Google & Apple. It is these very upholders of "Western" values who have colluded with the Communist Party of China to bring about the situation of which Mr Schmidt is whingeing. It is precisely the ruthless grasp of every lever of power, and control over information which provides the cheap labour to make Nexus & iPad.

I'm not praising the Communist Party of China. On the contrary they really are every bit as unprincipled & dangerous as Mr Schmidt says, but this shouldn't blind us to dangers nearer to home....

By wittgenfrog on 4 Feb 2013

Where are...

Google, Apple etc. based? American ideal of fair play? Seems like a few American companies have forgotten about that over the last few years.

By big_D on 4 Feb 2013

Leave a comment

You need to Login or Register to comment.



Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest ReviewsSubscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Real World Computing


Sponsored Links

Your email:

Your password:

remember me


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.