ISPs profit from coughing up customer data
By Stewart Mitchell
Posted on 27 Sep 2010 at 14:03
ISPs are making a tidy profit from online piracy by charging up to the £120 to provide data on their customers, according to the Federation Against Software Theft (FAST).
Intellectual property rights holders have been at loggerheads with ISPs since the beginning of peer-to-peer file sharing, blaming bandwidth suppliers for allowing subscribers to download music, video and software from the web without paying.
Under UK law, rights holders can only obtain details of who was using an IP address when copyright material was downloaded by obtaining a court order.
Once they have the necessary documentation, copyright holders can approach ISPs for information from their logs, but they have to pay a hefty charge for the service.
In the end we got about 100 names out of them, but that cost us £12,000
“In 2006, we ran Operation Tracker in which we identified about 130 users who were sharing copies of a security program over the web,” said John Lovelock, chief executive of FAST.
“In the end we got about 100 names out of them, but that cost us £12,000, and that was on top of the investigative costs and the legal fees.”
If it is a criminal case, the ISPs have to give up the information and can charge to recover costs, but in civil cases ISPs can almost name their price for the information.
“There's no uniformity - sometimes it's £85/hour or sometimes it is £100 per contact,” said Lovelock. “But they certainly charge a lot of money.”
ISPs are currently up in arms over being asked to pay 25% of the costs of establishing a system for sending out warning letters under the Digital Ecomony Act, with ISPs hinting that costs of the scheme would be passed on to customers.
Top stories on PC Pro
1) Why Google shouldn't clean up search
2) Piracy law firm leak raises privacy concerns
3) Hotmail security upgrade: too little, too late
4) How to store website data with HTML5
5) Developers: Android's a better long-term bet than Apple
Lovelock also called on Ofcom, which is involved in negotiations over how the system would work, not to allow ISPs to increase their data processing charges to cover their share of the costs.
“Ofcom is in the equation as we try to seek an agreement and ISPs will have to convince them that the systems are fair,” he said.
The ISP Association said it didn't have any limits on how ISPs should charge, but did say they had a right to recover the costs of supplying details.
"ISPA doesn’t have any agreed guidelines, but individual ISPs may have agreements with rights holders in order to cover costs of the data retrieval," a spokesperson said. "This is similar to the help ISPs give to serious law enforcement cases in which ISPs are entitled to recover their costs."
Dear Mr Lovelock
Ah, diddums.Never mind.
By KevinWMoor on 27 Sep 2010
Maybe John Lovelock's time is free?
£120 for having a member of ISP staff hunt though log files to match IP addresses to user ID's and be SURE of the answer would take some time, even assuming they didn't have to restore data from backups.
How much does FAST charge for the hour?
I'm betting this is a day rate with a half-day minimum and (as usual) the worst possible spin has been applied.
£120 per half-day for searches, not £120 per person.
By cheysuli on 27 Sep 2010
I think they would charge like 12000 pounds just per case, so they would be making lots of money anyways. in my opinion the the ISP should charge like 1000 pounds per contact for retrieving the information, that would put those little piggies in their spot (talking of course about these people who go on the hunt for "pirates")D
By mobilegnet on 27 Sep 2010
Ahh well, anyone see Jamie's Amercian Revolution last night..........
By a_byrne22 on 28 Sep 2010
- Flickr redesign: is it enough to tempt photographers back?
- Hands on with the new Google Maps
- Nokia Lumia 925 review: first look
- Why I won't subscribe to Creative Cloud
- GoPro camera strapped to a remote-control helicopter: the ultimate boy's toy
- Acer Iconia A1 review: first look
- Acer Aspire P3 review: first look
- Acer Aspire R7 review: first look
- How we produce the PC Pro podcast
- Google Now draining iPhone battery
- ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite
- Webroot Internet Security Essentials
- Trend Micro Internet Security
- PC Tools Internet Security 2009
- Panda Internet Security 2009
- Norton Internet Security 2009
- Kaspersky Internet Security 2009
- F-Secure Internet Security 2009
- AVG Internet Security 8
- BullGuard Internet Security 8.5