Campaigners turn up heat over fibre boxes
By Stewart Mitchell
Posted on 8 Sep 2010 at 16:07
The ill-feeling against BT's bulky new fibre-to-the-cabinet street furniture looks likely to spread, with consumer concerns being taken up by campaign group Civic Voice.
Back in July, residents in Brighton launched an attack on BT's 1.6m street cabinets and the animosity is apparently taking hold.
Civic Voice is to meet with BT Openreach on 22 September to raise its concerns and has a hit list of issues it wants addressing.
The campaigners claimed they are not nimbys and understand the need for a broadband Britain, but said fibre roll-out street cabinets should be sited and designed with more sensitivity.
“Civic Voice is finding too many of these broadband boxes are being poorly located, inflexibly designed and made unnecessarily intrusive,” said campaign spokesman Ian Harvey. “We're calling on BT to go through a number of tests before siting this equipment.”
The campaign's chief gripes are a lack of consultation with local residents and the minimal regulation applied to positioning boxes.
“The new broadband boxes stand 1.6m high and do not require planning consent,” said Harvey. “Even in conservation areas, national parks and areas of outstanding natural beauty local planning authorities need only be notified of proposals.
"A legal presumption that such infrastructure should be undergrounded in conservation areas is seemingly ignored on the grounds of questionable “technical difficulties” and “huge cost”.
Civic Voice said it had around 80 community groups involved in a “street clutter” campaign and claimed a high proportion of those groups had complained about street cabinets.
The campaign clan will march on BT armed with a seven-point checklist it believes BT should be address when positioning boxes – among them earlier involvement of local communities, planning safeguards and a choice of colour.
BT said is would work with local authorities to minimise impact.
"The installation of this new equipment, necessary to deliver faster speeds over a fibre network, is essential if residents and businesses in these areas are to reap the benefits of this new technology," the company said in a statement.
"But we are committed to working with local authorities to minimise the visual impact of the new street cabinets, and have done this successfully in other areas.”
From around the web
Campaigners turn up heat over fibre boxes
let that be there choice to have ordinary broadband.
warwickshire where I live, they are more than welcome to increase the 3.5 mbs speed that I have
By invalidscreenname on 8 Sep 2010 ![]()
There are aprox 80,000 of the existing street cabinets in the UK. That's a lot of extra hardware and although there is bound to be some nimby element it is also likely that many boxes will be badly or inappropriately located without some process.
By milliganp on 9 Sep 2010 ![]()
in the hole
simple,
dig a hole and chuck it in.
it can't really be that hard to bury the kit.
By darkhairedlord on 9 Sep 2010 ![]()
underground
Totally agree with darkhairedlord.
Take out a couple of paving slabs, put the same 1.6m cabinet horizontally in the hole and cover in with an access hatch.
Ok it might take a couple of days to dig a hole and put it in but providing your not putting it 6 feet under and covered in earth it will be just as accessible
By Andrew_C on 9 Sep 2010 ![]()
@ darkhairedlord & Andrew_C can your arm reach 1.6 metres down a hole?
To the cabinet the hole would have to be a lot wider and in a lot of places there isn't room.
I agree that it could be better organised and placed in a lot of cases, but not all. May be a selection of different cases would help enable them to blend in.
By AlSomething1 on 9 Sep 2010 ![]()
@AlSomething1
Even I can tell that Andrew_C isn't built like a gorilla, he suggests placing the box horizontally. Not so sure about darkhairedlord though :)
By Shuflie on 9 Sep 2010 ![]()
Burying the box is possible
It's one of the designs availible for these boxes.
It just costs more to install - for a few installations, that's not too much of a problem
- However, over the entire roll-out program, it adds up and is an extra cost that BT doesn't want.
By greemble on 10 Sep 2010 ![]()
Burying the boxes horizontally sounds like an easy solution. But what are you going to do with the other services that run underground - gas, water, electricity. All of which are usually in close proximity to telephone and cable ducting.
Moving the other services pipes and ducting is expensive and disruptive.
By chapelgarth on 11 Sep 2010 ![]()
advertisement
- How to install Internet Explorer 9
- Maintaining and supporting IE9
- Plan your deployment
- Creating a custom browser package
- Search in corporate environments
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- Amazon Kindle Fire review: first look
- Lytro light-field camera: first look
- CES: Why booth babes are bad marketing
- ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite
- Webroot Internet Security Essentials
- Trend Micro Internet Security
- PC Tools Internet Security 2009
- Panda Internet Security 2009
- Norton Internet Security 2009
- Kaspersky Internet Security 2009
- F-Secure Internet Security 2009
- AVG Internet Security 8
- BullGuard Internet Security 8.5
advertisement
