Emails reveal Apple and Google's no-poaching deal
Posted on 18 Jan 2013 at 10:28
Internal emails show that executives at tech companies including Apple and Google believed that an agreement to refrain from poaching each other's workers would bring real financial benefits.
Five former employees of various tech companies have filed a civil lawsuit against Apple, Google, Intel and others, alleging an illegal conspiracy to eliminate competition for each other's employees.
At a hearing in a California federal court, US District Judge Lucy Koh also ordered Apple chief executive Tim Cook to be questioned by plaintiff attorneys for four hours.
I find it hard to believe a COO would have no say over salary and compensation for all employees
Koh must decide whether the lawsuit can proceed as a class action, which would give the plaintiffs more leverage to extract a large settlement. Koh said that at the time the no-poaching agreements were forged, top executives felt a collective approach toward hiring was more efficient than dealing with employees individually.
"That, I think, is the biggest problem for the defendants," said Koh, who did not identify the executives. However, Koh also closely questioned a key economic analysis commissioned by the plaintiffs, which the judge said had "holes."
Koh did not rule on the class action issue during the hearing.
In 2010, Google, Apple, Adobe, Intel, Intuit and Walt Disney's Pixar unit agreed to a settlement of a US Justice Department probe that bars them from agreeing to refrain from poaching each other's employees.
The Justice Department and California state antitrust regulators then sued eBay late last year over an alleged no-poaching deal with Intuit. eBay said the government is wrong, and has not been named as a defendant in the civil lawsuit.
Plaintiff attorneys have estimated that civil damages could potentially run into hundreds of millions of dollars.
In court on Thursday, Adobe attorney Robert Mittelstaedt said the plaintiffs had no evidence that employees were actually impacted by the no-cold call deals. "It's not in the data," Mittelstaedt said.
In 2007, Apple's Steve Jobs asked former Google chief executive Eric Schmidt to stop trying to recruit an Apple engineer, a transgression that threatened one junior Google employee's job, according to a court filing last year. At the time, Schmidt was an Apple board member.
Koh criticised attorneys for the tech companies for being too slow to schedule depositions of top executives. Apple attorney George Riley attempted to spare Cook from a deposition, saying that when Cook was chief operating officer of the company before succeeding Jobs in 2011, Cook had no role in any of the no-hire agreements.
"I find it hard to believe a COO would have no say over salary and compensation for all employees," Koh responded.
Additionally, Google attorneys agreed that Schmidt, now Google's executive chairman, could be questioned by plaintiffs' lawyers on 20 February. Executives from several other companies were also scheduled for depositions, including Intel chief executive Paul Otellini.
Is your business a social business? For helpful info and tips visit our hub.
- Tim Cook: this is how much TV has changed since the 70s
- Westminster wins the .London battle
- 20 years of PC Pro: from deep pan pizza to virtualisation
- Five reasons why the Apple Watch leaves me cold
- Apple Watch, iPhone 6 and 6 Plus: Tim Cook's Apple back with a bang?
- BT Home Hub 5: how to get maximum speed
- 20 years of PC Pro: one-star reviews (including "the worst tablet we've ever seen")
- 20 years of PC Pro: our best covers
- Why we've closed the PC Pro forums
- How to turn off Google Location Tracking
- How to sell more ebooks on Amazon
- 10 ways to make your business more secure
- Top five VoIP mistakes
- How to add in-app purchasing to an iPhone, Android or Windows app
- Remote-control ransomware: TeamViewer and software hardball
- Why laptops with serial ports matter to the Internet of Things
- Make your mobile battery last longer
- Small steps into handling Big Data
- Nexus 5: does it really run stock Android?
- How to get broadband to a garden office