Amazon's domain name land grab disputed... by Australia
By Nicole Kobie
Posted on 22 Nov 2012 at 11:30
Governments around the world have filed complaints against a land grab on new top-level domains being created by ICANN - with the UK arguing against one: rugby.
ICANN, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, is opening up new terms to be used in top-level domains - the end of a web address such as ".com" or ".co.uk".
The move has led to a land grab for terms such as ".book" or ".search", with large corporations and small registry start-ups looking to get control of such TLDs.
The move attracted 1,930 applications - at a whopping $185,000 per domain - and now ICANN is working through disputes from companies asking for the same term and from interested parties complaining about generic terms being bought up and controlled by private firms.
Amazon is proposing to exclude any other entities, including potential competitors, from using the TLD
ICANN has released a list of potential TLDs complained about by governments, revealing a third of Amazon's initial 75 applications have been disputed.
Amazon's land grab garnered 28 complaints, mostly from Australia, which said terms such as "app", "book", "game" and "news" should be open for everyone, while Brazil and Peru even argued against the retailer trying to buy ".amazon" - saying the URL should be open to people doing conservation work in the actual Amazon.
The complaints don't mean the application will be blocked, but could lead to stipulations in the contract with ICANN guaranteeing other groups the right to use the TLD.
"Amazon is proposing to
exclude any other entities, including potential competitors, from using the TLD," Australia noted in a filing. "Restricting common generic strings for the exclusive use of a single entity could have unintended consequences, including a negative impact on competition."
"Amazon should specify transparent criteria for third-party access to the TLD," Australia added. "These criteria should be appropriate for the types of risk associated with the TLD, and should not set anti-competitive or discriminatory conditions relating to access by third parties."
Five of Google's 103 TLD applications were also disputed with complaints including "app", "cloud," and "search", while Symantec's claims to "antivirus" and "cloud" were also under fire.
Overall, Australia argued against the most TLD names - a total 130 out of the 242 complaints filed, including ".wtf" and ".blog".
It disputed the use of the online acronym as a TLD saying it has "an overtly negative or critical connotation" and the applicant, a company called Hidden Way, wouldn't be able to support a "high number of defensive registrations" - such as by large firms looking to protect their brand.
Australia argued ".blog" and other widely used words including ".search" and ".town" were simply too generic to be controlled by a single firm.
The UK stepped in on a single term - ".rugby" - and then only because three groups applied. The UK authorities chose to back the International Rugby Board, saying it was the official governing body for the sport, asking the other two firms to withdraw their applications.
Governments aren't the only ones that can file complaints with ICANN. Anyone with an interest - such as competing companies - can also dispute the new TLDs. That consultation process is still ongoing, so it's not yet clear exactly which names will end up in use when the new domains are announced next year.
Is your business a social business? For helpful info and tips visit our hub.
And yet Rugby town was denied?
Domain camping is like patent trolling. A sleazy business.
By cheysuli on 22 Nov 2012
Its dead in the water
If there has to be so many consultations and everyone can object to any name put forward this idea is already dead in the water as would take centuries to resolve,
I can not see what is wrong with .UK,.com .au.eu etc.
By curiousclive on 23 Nov 2012
- CeBit 2014 diary: Cameron comes to town
- The 5 most interesting UK businesses at SXSW
- Quickest way to upload 1GB? Hop on a train
- Move over Delia: IBM Watson is cooking tonight
- Eric Schmidt on the double-edged smartphone: friend and foe
- Getty joins the race to the bottom
- Hour of Code: five steps to learn how to code
- Sony Xperia Z2 Tablet review: first look
- Sony Xperia Z2 review: first look
- Samsung Galaxy Gear 2 review: first look
- Headings vs headers: how to use both in Word
- Windows Server 2012 R2: how the Datacenter edition could change SMBs
- Invoices and VAT: how to set up your documents correctly
- Nexus 5 vs Samsung Galaxy S4 Active: the best phone for avoiding screen burn
- How much is a social user worth?
- The key to choosing a secure password
- Thunderbolt Bridge: a fast Mac migration tool
- Should you advertise on Twitter?
- How to track a lost smartphone
- Self-publishing success: the best way to sell your book