How much are Google's Motorola patents really worth?

13 Nov 2012
Motorola Atrix

Court to decide how much Microsoft should pay Google for access to Motorola patents in critical hearing

Microsoft and Google's Motorola Mobility unit are set to square off today at a trial which could reveal financial information the two companies usually keep under wraps.

The proceeding in a Seattle federal court will determine how much of a royalty Microsoft should pay Google for a licence to some of Motorola's patents. Google bought Motorola for $12.5 billion, partly for its library of communications patents.

If District Judge James Robart decides Google deserves only a small royalty, then its Motorola patents would be a weaker bargaining chip for Google to negotiate licensing deals with rivals.

Apple and Microsoft have been litigating in courts around the world against Google and partners such as Samsung, which use the Android operating system on their mobile devices.

Apple contends that Android is basically a copy of its iOS smartphone software, and Microsoft holds patents that it contends cover a number of Android features.

Motorola had sought up to $4 billion a year for its wireless and video patents, while Microsoft argues its rival deserves just over $1 million a year. A federal judge in Wisconsin last week threw out a similar case brought by Apple against Google just before trial.

During the run-up to trial in Seattle, both Microsoft and Google asked Robart to keep secret a range of financial details about the two companies, including licensing deals and sales revenue projections. Google requested that Robart clear the courtroom when witnesses discuss those details.

However, in an order on Monday, Robart rejected that request. The public will not be able to view the documents describing patent deals or company sales during trial, Robart ruled, but testimony will be in open court.

"If a witness discloses pertinent terms, rates or payments, such information will necessarily be made public," the judge wrote.

Additionally, any documents the judge relies on for his final opinion will be disclosed.

Representatives for Microsoft and Google could not immediately comment on the ruling.

Read more

News