Developer claims phone software spies on millions
By Stewart Mitchell
Posted on 30 Nov 2011 at 11:46
A mobile phone analytics tool has been accused of snooping on millions of consumers, despite the manufacturer denying it logged user actions.
Android app developer Trevor Eckhart has posted a video in which he claims to prove millions of smartphones are monitoring the location, key presses and messages of users via the Carrier IQ software.
Carrier IQ, which says it provides tools for carriers to better understand subscribers, had insisted after earlier accusations from Eckhart that it didn't log keystrokes during its information gathering. However, in a video posted on YouTube the developer showed how the software collected this data.
Using packet sniffing software, Eckhart showed how data was logged both when connected to a wireless network and when in “airplane mode”.
The permissions list is pretty extensive, everything from calling numbers and stuff that costs money to reading messages, location and recording audio
"The permissions list is pretty extensive, everything from calling numbers and stuff that costs money to reading messages, location and recording audio," he said in the video.
According to the researcher, the HTC device used for the demonstration was not rooted and had been factory reset, but he stressed the software ran on Nokia and Blackberry handsets too.
Carrier IQ itself claims to be installed on more than 140 miilion handsets after being embedded by device manufacturers.
We are waiting to hear back from Carrier IQ for its comments on the claims.
From around the web
!
I don't know alot about Android handsets but capturing HTTPS traffic is pretty bad. Does this software need embedding by the manufacture or could any installed software do this?
If so its a pretty massive security problem for the whole platform.
By JStairmand on 30 Nov 2011 ![]()
rootkit
It would seem Carrier IQ is essentially a rootkit installed by the manufacture / carrier. Carrier IQ have posted an explanation (which might be wrong if Eckhart's results are accurate) on their website at http://www.carrieriq.com/Media_Alert_User_Experien
ce_Matters_11_16_11.pdf
By milliganp on 30 Nov 2011 ![]()
!
I don't know alot about Android handsets but capturing HTTPS traffic is pretty bad. Does this software need embedding by the manufacture or could any installed software do this?
If so its a pretty massive security problem for the whole platform.
By JStairmand on 30 Nov 2011 ![]()
Not only android
"he stressed the software ran on Nokia and Blackberry handsets too!"
this has nothing to do with android it self!
"Carrier IQ itself claims to be installed on more than 140 miilion handsets after being embedded by device manufacturers"
It should be the manufacturers that we should be worried about!
By sandman652001 on 30 Nov 2011 ![]()
If this is true it is extremely worrying. How could such a massive invasion of privacy be legal? Would also be a huge blow to blackberry security reputation.
By JamesD29 on 30 Nov 2011 ![]()
Storm in a teacup?
He shows the CIQ software is there and running.
He shows all the keystrokes are captured by USB Debugging.
He does not show any relationship between CIQ and USB Debugging.
I'm no expert, but 'USB Debugging' sounds like it is a tool for debugging over USB. I would assume it captures and records all events for the purpose of debugging.
There is no "packet sniffing" going on here.
Now, if he were to switch Debugging OFF, and actually capture all this same stuff over the air using "packet sniffing software", that would be different. But he hasn't. All he shows is that USB debugging works as expected.
By martindaler on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
Not on my htc
I'm running an unbranded Sensation and the software he is talking about in the video isn't present.
Is this only applicable to carrier branded phones?
By big_D on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
@martindaler
I've just finished watching the whole video and I have to agree with you, he does not show any packet sniffing.
He show USB debug mode, so it isn't surprising that the https request is being shown in the clear, as this is the browser outputting debug information to the USB port, this is NOT what is being sent out over the air! In the first part of the video, he is using Airplane mode and it is still showing the debug information, so it has nothing to do with packet sniffing!
I agree with your comment about turning off USB debugging and turning on packet sniffing.
It would be interesting to see what then happens, whether this information ever leaves the phone, or not.
As I said in my previous comment, the software isn't even installed on my device.
This is the second security scare using htc devices as the example and this is the second time that I've found that my htc Sensation doesn't have the noted software installed.
I'm sorry to say, that this is very poor reporting on PC Pros part.
To call USB Debugging "packet sniffing" is horse hockey and the information in the video isn't showing us anything useful.
A little more research next time, before putting up such scare stories, please.
By big_D on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
Also on iPhone?
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/12/01/ios_has_ca
rrier_iq_client/
Reports say the software is also to be found on iPhones...
What next? Windows Phone as well?
By big_D on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
...but then again
CIQ is pretty much damned by its own website:
http://www.carrieriq.com/overview/IQInsightService
Analyzer/index.htm
they even show a sample data capture, mapped to show location, together with call start and end times "measured at the point of delivery – in the mobile phone – to provide an unparalleled level of quantitative information".
OK, so no record of the number dialled, but do I need anybody other than my carrier to know where, when and for how long I made calls on my individual device?
By martindaler on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
... and they carry on
"IQ Insight gives you more than just data – it provides the monitoring and drill-down capabilities to move seamlessly from analysis of a group of devices containing as many as several million active users, through to detailed inspection of data from specific devices and events of interest. The ability to switch effortlessly from the "telescope" view of a population of a large number of users right down to "microscope" analysis of individual devices and events is a unique capability of IQ Insight."
http://www.carrieriq.com/overview/IQInsightDatacar
dAnalyzer/index.htm
By martindaler on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
At least...
it is US only (at the moment).
The data only goes to CIQ and the carriers - when it works "right"... :-S
By big_D on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
More information
I've found more information on this, along with quotes from manufacturers and network carriers, over at engadget.
www.engadget.com/2011/12/01/carrier-iq-what-it-is-
what-it-isnt-and-what-you-need-to/
By mviracca on 1 Dec 2011 ![]()
advertisement
- Laptop bag reviews: nine tested
- Sony VAIO T Series Ultrabook review: first look
- Revealed: the military standards and robots HP uses to test its laptops
- Windows 8: multi-monitors and double standards?
- Why is TalkTalk's year-old porn filter suddenly big news?
- Why are laptop screens so far behind mobiles?
- HP EliteBook Folio review: first look
- The shoebox-sized all-in-one printer
- Forget the Ultrabook: here comes the HP Sleekbook
- HP Spectre XT review: first look
- Why you have to be left in the dark on OS patches
- Is Microsoft mismanaging Windows on ARM?
- Dealing with spam surrogates
- Why 3G broadband can be better and cheaper than ADSL
- Is Twitter bad for business?
- Publishing your email address isn't a security disaster
- Why you'll need a fax machine to develop iOS apps
- Learning to adapt to the mobile web
- Why you shouldn't use WPS on your Wi-Fi network
- Disabled users suffer when software breaks the rules
advertisement
