ISPs block millions of legitimate emails
By Stewart Mitchell
Posted on 12 Aug 2010 at 14:09
ISPs are blocking millions of legitimate emails a day as collateral damage in their war against spam, according to an email delivery company.
The worst hit are social networks. Friends Reunited, for example, had as many as 27% of its emails bulk blocked by ISPs in May, according to Return Path, which advises companies how to get messages through to end users.
We're not talking about spam, these are emails that people have asked to receive
“About one in five commercial permission-based emails are being blocked globally, and 15% in Europe are blocked because ISPs are treating them as spam,” Margaret Farmakis, senior director of response consulting for Return Path, told PC Pro. "I wouldn't be able to say if it was millions or billions, but it is countless.
“We're not talking about spam, these are emails that people have asked to receive, but that are being treated like spam,” she said. “It doesn't effect one-to-one emails, but a lot of marketing emails and communications from social networks, for example, are never delivered to the end user.”
According to Return Path, email is often caught in the spam trap because some end users flag emails as unsolicited when actually they have just got bored of receiving emails from a company. If a company receives too many spam reports – around 1% of mails from any one company – then all emails from that company are tarred with the same brush.
Social networks are increasingly falling into ISPs' spam filters because of the way subscribers sign up to the services, with networks often suggesting that users import email address books.
Return Path said emails from social networks were twice as likely to be caught up in the ISP bulking traps than mails from other industries.
“The practice of importing loads of addresses can have an impact,” said Farmakis. “Effectively you are sending a lot of emails to people who haven't asked for them, and some of those email addresses could be really old, which might be out of use or being used as spam traps. It can be risky.”
Despite the high number of false positives, Farmakis refused to blame ISPs for the wrongly blocked missives, saying that some legitimate emails were inevitably going to be caught in the crossfire.
“Between 97% and 98% of all email is spam,” she said. “ISPs have to weed through it and try and discover what they should deliver and when they should protect their end users from spam. It's like they're fishing and if a company's email looks too much like spam they get caught up in the net.”
Twitter's permanently asking me to change my email or confirm that the address is correct due to emails being rejected by my email provider
By malfranks2 on 12 Aug 2010
Surely if all SMTP postoffices had certification?
Then any "uncertified" mail could be rejected.
Any using their own SMTP or a bot-infected PC sending SPAM would be easily weeded out.
Anyone could get their SMPT post office certified, but equally anyone sending spam gets their certificate revoked.
There are holes in any system, but there are plenty of smart people out there so why is nothing being done?
Is spam filtering just too lucrative an industry?
By cheysuli on 12 Aug 2010
"a lot of marketing emails"
For the most part, that pretty well defines spam as far as I can see
I know the marketing dept. see e-mail as a wonderful way of informing their customers about the latest 'special offer' or some new 'must have' product - but it's still just an advert as far as I'm concerned and I don't want lots of junk mail in my inbox.
Yes, a lot has be 'given permission' - just try buying from or registering with some sites without them demanding an e-mail address that can be used to 'keep you informed'
By greemble on 12 Aug 2010
This will continue to happen until companies stop hiding the unsubscribe information at the bottom of the email.
They will also have to stop asking for a username and password - all the data they need to unsubscribe the respondent is in the email header.
By Mark_Thompson on 12 Aug 2010
- Huawei Ascend P6 review: first look
- Adobe Illustrator CC review: first look
- Let MPs tell us what they really want ISPs to block
- Adobe Photoshop CC review: first look
- WWDC 2013 and iOS 7 launch: live blog
- Sony VAIO Pro review: first look
- Want child porn blocked? Meet the IWF
- Is it worth upgrading a media centre to Windows 8?
- Flickr redesign: is it enough to tempt photographers back?
- Hands on with the new Google Maps
- Facebook "click on the photo" scams: how they work
- Three alternatives to Word's spelling and grammar checker
- Google two-step verification: a must for business email
- Microsoft Office and the death of upgrades
- The ICO's shame-faced u-turn on cookies
- Start8 and ModernMix: making Windows 8 work on a desktop
- How to boost your mobile reception
- How to fix Facebook: Social Fixer
- Taking the stress out of WordPress updates
- Where to download free web fonts