EU rakes over Microsoft's browser ballot proposal
By Barry Collins and Reuters
Posted on 12 Feb 2012 at 21:12
European Union antitrust regulators are seeking to ensure that Microsoft's offer to give users the chance to choose rivals' web browsers is workable for consumers and its rivals.
Microsoft proposes to install a ballot screen in Windows that will allow users to set up rival browsers during the installation process, a move which could end a decade-long dispute with the EU.
The Commission has to date slapped a total 1.68 billion euros (£1.5bn) in fines on Microsoft for infringing EU antitrust rules.
A confidential Commission questionnaire obtained by Reuters shows regulators were concerned whether users would understand they were being offered a choice of browsers and whether they would actually use the ballot screen.
"In your view, is the proposed approach to downloading and installing competing browsers as seamless and straightforward as necessary from a user experience perspective for the ballot screen to be used effectively to exercise consumer choice between competing web browsers?" the questionnaire asked.
It also asked respondents to comment on the proposed design and implementation of the ballot screen. The questionnaire was dated from July, with a late August deadline set for replies. The Commission hasn't disclosed when it will decide on Microsoft's offer.
If the questionnaire landed on the doormat at Mozilla, it's unlikely to have elicited a positive response. The Firefox maker has heavily criticised the ballot scheme, claiming it will do little to alter the status quo in the browser market.
In an interview with the International Herald Tribune last week, Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes said she wanted to reach a deal with Microsoft before her term ends this year.
From around the web
Last minute
So, after the Windows 7 E nonsense, there is still no final decision. It's now too late to make any changes to the Windows 7 release in Europe. The EU is still looking at an 'antitrust' issue regarding browsers which was only relevant a decade ago.
By Stiggy on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Cash cow
Do they know there's a deadline?
Oh, silly me, I'm sure M$ can just delay the release until the bureaucrats finish 'thinking'.
Either that, or the EU is waiting until after the release, - and fine M$ yet again for something...
By greemble on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Dumming down
Once again eutocrats think everyone else is too thick to know what a choice of browsers is.
By darkhairedlord on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Dumming down
Once again eutocrats think everyone else is too thick to know what a choice of browsers is.
By darkhairedlord on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Duplicate posts
great aren't they!
And spreading thier contagion
By darkhairedlord on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Naive
Q: The EU will never let us get away with a ballot screen, what shall we do?
A: Stall the EU with that silly 'E edition' idea then introduce the ballot screen when it's too late for them to intervene.
By Mark_Thompson on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
"Stall the EU with that silly 'E edition' idea then introduce the ballot screen when it's too late for them to intervene."
And then wait for the EU to hit us with yet another anti-trust fine.
Brilliant!
By greemble on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Not the EU's problem
The EC needs to get its decision right at the first attempt, this takes time, like all these antitrust cases do.
The release of Windows 7 is Microsofts problem, not the problem of the EC. It doesn't make sense that the EC should rush its investigation because Microsoft is launching a new product. Microsoft isn't forced to bundle Internet Explorer with Windows 7, and can stop so at any moment, regardless of where the EC is in its decisionmaking proces.
Honestly, it's very simple. If Microsoft is convinced that its bundling of Internet Explorer is legal (which I doubt), it should continue to do so and aim to win this thing in the European Court. If not, then it should have never started the bundling, and not be surprised when it faces another big fine.
By Woudenberg on 28 Sep 2009 ![]()
Presumably MS has put a Cancel option on the ballot screen, so users can 'just get on with it' and never be 'troubled' with a choice again!
Of course MS wants to get its product launched, but its not like either the court case or the Win7 launch has not been coming for a long time, so MS could have chosen to allow more time.
I'd love to see the EU stand up to the predictably self-serving tactics of some of the world's larger monopolies....and then disband itself!
By davidsoap on 29 Sep 2009 ![]()
@Woudenberg
"Microsoft isn't forced to bundle Internet Explorer with Windows 7, and can stop so at any moment, regardless of where the EC is in its decisionmaking proces."
Isn't that what they were proposing with the release of the E version of windows 7? Look how far that got them, the EC complained that it was even worse for the consumer than the regular bundled version. I don't think they will be happy unless the users get a choice of installing every broswer other than IE8 when windows is installing.
By Shuflie on 30 Sep 2009 ![]()
advertisement
- Chrome's shine getting lost in translation
- BytePac: the cardboard hard disk enclosure
- How tech loosens our grip on reality
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- Why virtualisation hasn't slowed the growth of data
- How to make Google AdWords work for your business
- The curse of sloppily written software
- Paying for your crimes with Bitcoin
- Behind the scenes: tech support for Formula 1
- The security risk of fat fingers
- Why Windows Phone 7 isn't quite ready for business
- When will Microsoft stop fiddling with Windows 8?
- Flash down the pan?
- Metro Style apps vs desktop applications
advertisement
