US re-opens mobile phone cancer debate

 

Gallery

By Reuters

Posted on 15 Sep 2009 at 08:11

US senator Tom Harkin - newly empowered to investigate health matters as chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labour and Pensions Committee - has promised to probe deeply into any potential links between mobile phone use and cancer.

Harkin, who took over the committee earlier this month after the death of Massachusetts Senator Edward Kennedy, says he is concerned no one has been able to prove mobile phones do not cause cancer.

"I'm reminded of this nation's experience with cigarettes," Harkin says. "Decades passed between the first warnings about smoking tobacco and the final definitive conclusion that cigarettes cause lung cancer."

Decades passed between the first warnings about smoking tobacco and the final definitive conclusion that cigarettes cause lung cancer

Mobile phones, used by four billion people worldwide, use radio waves. Years of research has failed to establish any clear link between their use and several kinds of cancer, including brain tumours.

Recent worries have been raised by the Environmental Working Group, an activist group, and epidemiologist Devra Lee Davis of the University of Pittsburgh, who has written a book alleging the US Government has overlooked many potential sources of cancer.

Harkin called a hearing of the Appropriations Committee's Subcommittee on Labour, Health and Human Services, and Education to look into the questions. "I will pursue this beyond this panel, with NIH [the National Institutes of Health]," Harkin said after the hearing.

A staffer claims the senator became concerned by a report from the Environmental Working Group showing that radio wave emissions vary from one mobile phone brand and model to another; as well as reports suggesting there might be a link.

No evidence

Linda Erdreich of science and engineering firm Exponent in New York claims 50 years' worth of evidence had failed to show that mobile phones can cause cancer.

"This part of the spectrum is known as non-ionising radiation," she told the hearing, explaining that this means radio waves cannot damage the DNA in cells.

But Pennsylvania Senator Arlen Specter pressed her on this, asking her repeatedly whether science had conclusively proved there was no connection. "Your statement that it is hard to prove a negative is right on," Erdreich replied.

"What comes through to me is that we just don't know what the answer is," said Specter, a cancer survivor who said he avoids white flour and sugar in case it might feed tumours.