Windows 7 to dial down UAC

 

Gallery

By Stuart Turton

Posted on 10 Oct 2008 at 10:50

Engineers working on Windows 7 have admitted Vista's User Account Control was too intrusive, and are promising to tone it down in the forthcoming Windows 7.

"We've heard loud and clear that you are frustrated," says Microsoft engineer Ben Fathi, in a posting on the Windows 7 engineering blog. "You find the prompts too frequent, annoying, and confusing. We still want to provide you control over what changes can happen to your system, but we want to provide you a better overall experience."

According to Fathi, when Vista first launched, 775,312 unique applications were producing prompts, mainly because "much of the software ecosystem unnecessarily required admin privileges to run."

This, he claims, has fallen to 168,149 as developers have adapted to Vista's new requirements. He also argues that number of sessions marred by one or more UAC prompts has declined from 50% to 33%.

Although some may be disappointed to hear that UAC will not be scrapped, Fathi has promised to "evolve" the feature for the next version of Windows, based on customer feedback.

"The benefits UAC has provided to the ecosystem and Windows are clear; we need to continue that work," says Fathi in the post.

"Moving forward we will look at the scenarios we think are most important for our users so we can ensure none of these scenarios include prompts that can be avoided."

The comments echo those of Steve Ballmer, who admitted at a conference in London that "the biggest trade off we made was sacrificing security for compatibility. I'm not sure the end-users really appreciated that trade off."

Read our feature on the new features of Windows 7, and why you don't have to wait for them, in this month's PC Pro.

PC Pro's top five stories:

5. Work out your carbon netprint