Best mice alternatives for 2013
Posted on 29 Aug 2013 at 10:23
Which alternative to the traditional mouse is best for your desk? Find out in our alternative pointer shoot-out
If you suffer from RSI, the culprit could well be your mouse. But never fear, there’s a host of alternatives on the market that can alleviate the strain. We’ve spent the past month using five to find out which is best.
Logitech TrackMan Marble
The cheapest mouse alternative in this roundup by far is the Logitech TrackMan Marble. It’s a basic, wired device, with four buttons sitting behind its large, red trackball, yet there’s nothing cheap-feeling about it. Cursor control is smooth and accurate, with the large red “marble” on its nose imparting a real quality feel to mousing activities. Because it’s so large, the ball is as easy to operate with a thumb as it is with the ends of your fingers. And it’s an ambidextrous design, so it’s at home on both left- and right-hand sides of the keyboard. The best thing about the TrackMan, however, is how easy it is to make the transition from mouse to ball. There’s one snag, and that’s the lack of a dedicated scrollwheel or button, which turns an otherwise excellent device into an also-ran.
Price: £19 (£23 inc VAT)
Logitech T650 Wireless Rechargeable Touchpad
When Apple launched its Magic Trackpad back in 2010, it was a novelty; in 2013, with the advent of Windows 8, the concept of a large, desk-bound touchpad has become a more serious alternative for PC users. The T650 is Logitech’s take on the concept, and it’s just as well made as Apple’s version. The top is smooth, luxurious-feeling ground glass, and it offers mechanical clicking, multitouch tapping and Windows 8-friendly gesture support. Connection is via a small USB wireless receiver, and the touchpad can be recharged via a micro-USB connection. If you’ve been waiting for Windows 8 to make sense on the desktop, this almost helps. Two-fingered scrolling, panning and zooming is effortlessly achieved, as are Windows 8’s edge-swipes, and the T650 adds a few of its own. There are four-fingered Aero Snap, window maximise and minimise gestures, and you can swipe up and down with three fingers to bring up and dismiss the Windows 8 Start screen. In all, the T650 is a marvellous piece of kit. A little pricey, perhaps, but it’s a comfortable alternative to a mouse and brings Windows 8 to life.
Price: £50 (£60 inc VAT)
Contour RollerMouse Re:d and Free2
Of all our mousing alternatives, Contour’s RollerMouse devices are the most expensive. For the cost of the Free2, you could buy three Logitech touchpads and countless standard mice, and the Re:d is even more pricey. Are they worth the money? If you have chronic RSI, unquestionably yes. The concept is simple enough: the RollerMouse allows you to control your cursor by way of a cylindrical bar that spins forwards and backwards and slides from side to side. Below it are left-click and right-click buttons along with a scrollwheel and a sensitivity adjustment button, and the bar is also clickable. It’s a surprisingly intuitive way of controlling the cursor, and after a few days of using them, we found we hardly missed our mouse. We prefer the Re:d’s larger, more sensitive roller bar, but both devices deliver incredibly accurate and sensitive cursor control, allowing effortless selecting, dragging and dropping. And since they sit directly beneath the keyboard, you hardly have to move your hand to move the mouse. That’s good news for RSI sufferers, as is the ability to swap between left- and right-handed operation. The only downside – and it’s a big one – is that price.
Price: Re:d, £200 (£240 inc VAT); Free2, £183 (£220 inc VAT)
Logitech Wireless Trackball M570
Logitech’s Wireless Trackball M570 marries the shell of an oversized mouse with a large blue trackball on its left-hand edge. It’s a familiar shape and design for people used to using a traditional mouse, with a scrollwheel nestling between the two main mouse buttons and a pair of dedicated “back” and “forward” keys alongside. The buttons can be reassigned to different tasks if you don’t get on with these assignations. Since it’s wireless and doesn’t need to sit on a perfectly flat surface, the Trackball M570 can be used when you’re sitting on the sofa or using a laptop away from a desk. However, we did experience the occasional stutter while moving the cursor around our Windows desktop – something we hadn’t experienced with our bog-standard Microsoft mouse. The design isn’t ambidextrous, and if you’re looking for an alternative mouse because of wrist or hand complaints, the Trackball might not be the best option: having to constantly use our thumb quickly tired the muscles around the top of our hand. We found the Marble more comfortable to use, despite the lack of scrollwheel, and it’s cheaper, too.
Price: £35 (£42 inc VAT)
Author: Jonathan Bray
"Mice?" What happened to "mouses?" Dr Graham-Smith may correct me, but isn't "mouse" in computing terms a headless noun?
By captaintau on 29 Aug 2013
Of Mice and Men
Hi captain tau
The OED only has mice. Other sources haves mouses, Dr Engelbart himself said "mice" http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/tomchiversscienc
I really must get out more
By simontompkins on 29 Aug 2013
Contour RollerMouse Saved My Career
I was getting terrible RSI pains in my arms and right shoulder for many years.
I tried all sorts of devices - rollerballs, pointers and trackpads.
Only the Contour RollerMouse enabled me to carry on working pain free. I've been using it since I think 2002 and on my second one. A real career saver for me!
By cyberindie on 29 Aug 2013
It's disappointing that Logitech discontinued the wired version of the wireless M570 - still have my wired model and I'm pretty happy with it (was also £15 less than the wireless one). I preferred the Microsoft one it replaced but it didn't last
The M650 trackpad is also nice to have, definitely better in windows 8 and makes a massive improvement in performing the edge gestures - makes Windows 8 very usable.
By thewelshbrummie on 30 Aug 2013
pedantry alert! - It's in the 1st para
These are alternatives to a mouse.
By wittgenfrog on 30 Aug 2013
Lack Of Scroll Wheel Isn't A Problem.
A long-time convert to trackballs, I started using a Logitech Trackman Marble after my expensive Microsoft trackball stopped working after a few months' use.
The Microsoft model had a scroll wheel and I initially missed it. However, I soon got used to scrolling with the Logitech using the ball.
After over 7 years of extensive daily use, the Logitech is still going strong. It's extremely comfortable to use for long periods.
Great piece of kit!
By sonanti on 10 Sep 2013
you missed the out the best
Like other readers, trackballs saved/stopped my RSI. But you missed out the leader the T-RB22 Cordless Trackman. I've got both a M570 & a Marble. In fact I'm using that (a Marble) with my laptop, but with my desktop it has to BE a T-RB22, naught else! BC
By beecee on 24 Sep 2013
For more details about purchasing this feature and/or images for editorial usage, please contact Jasmine Samra on email@example.com
- Windows 8.2: release date, features and free cloud version
- Chrome Remote Desktop now available on Android
- Sony warns of fresh VAIO battery fires
- 4G version of Surface 2 launched in the UK
- BlackBerry CEO says not selling off phones "any time soon"
- 13 May: the day we'll know if Microsoft is really abandoning Windows XP
- Office for iPad hits 12m downloads, but receives poor reviews
- Windows Phone 8.1 gets its own PA: Cortana
- 24m vulnerable home routers ready to launch DDoS attacks
- Mozilla's Eich: my views on gay marriage are irrelevant
- Hello Cortana, it's nice to meet you
- Windows 8.1 Update: an abject surrender
- The insane economics of Sky Now TV
- No such thing as a free app... so pay up if you want quality
- Time to outlaw crapware-laden installers
- Windows Phone 8.1 video: hands-on
- Office for iPad: key information
- Why every PC buyer owes Richard Durkin a debt of gratitude
- HTC One M8 vs Samsung Galaxy S5: 2014's big-hitters compared
- Windows XP end of life: key information