Does open source need corporate backing to succeed?
Posted on 5 Aug 2011 at 15:44
Much of Android's success down to Google's backing, says researcher
Android is one of the most successful projects in the open-source world, but that's mostly because of Google's "muscle", according to one researcher.
Liz Laffan, an analyst at VisionMobile, has attempted to measure the "openness" of several open-source software platforms - ranking Google's OS in last place.
"Despite the widespread use of open source, from Android to WebKit, there is one very important aspect that has been neglected: openness and how to measure it," she said in an EU-sponsored report.
"In today’s world of commercially-led mobile open-source projects, it is not enough to understand the open-source licence used by a project," she argued. "It is the governance model that makes the difference between an 'open' and a 'closed' project."
It is the governance model that makes the difference between an 'open' and a 'closed' project
That governance includes aspects such as access to code, developer power, and the strength of the community. "We have attempted to quantify openness by understanding how decisions are made with regard to the project," she told PC Pro. "Over time no doubt we will refine our criteria and there may be more appropriate metrics identified for openness, but we believe that this is a good starting point to understanding openness in open-source projects."
She admitted it's difficult to compare such disparate projects as Mozilla, Android and WebKit, but said: "just like organisations can be big or small and have different cultures and processes, there are still ways to measure their financial success and identify their culture."
"Mozilla is unique in that it is the only project that created an organisation to manage its codebase. Android is also unique in that Google has hundreds of developers working on the project. WebKit is unique in that it has successfully managed a number of high-profile organisational contributors such as Apple, Nokia, Google, RIM and Palm," she said. "But we believe that you can still compare the ‘how’ and the ‘why’ of the open-source project – which is what we have tried to do."
With that in mind, by Laffan's reckoning, Android ranks last out of the eight top open-source projects examined, with a 23% openness score. Eclipse - a software development environment - was the highest ranked, with an 84% score, followed by Linux, WebKit and Mozilla.
While she praised Androids's simple contributions system and its multi-million dollar awards to encourage developers, Laffan criticised Google's tight control of the product roadmap and what code is used, saying there was a lack of transparency around the project.
It would be nice to see more of Industry taking up on Android - however I believe they have sold themselves off to MS - and that was some time ago.
By nicomo on 7 Aug 2011
Just repeat that for me...
"Our research suggests that platforms that are most open will be most successful in the long-term,"
So by that logic, Windows, Apple OS and Android will be less successful because they are closed? Sorry, are we not counting the last 30 years?
By mppreece on 9 Aug 2011
For more details about purchasing this feature and/or images for editorial usage, please contact Jasmine Samra on email@example.com
- Yahoo seeks "cool" with Tumblr purchase
- Dell profits slide 79% amid buyout talks
- Forget cloud subscriptions: users prefer standard licences
- McAfee: cloud storage could help spread viruses
- Analysts question Windows 8 as UK PC shipments slump
- McAfee: smart homes need security
- Firefox 21 lands with "health report" and Android update
- Windows Blue (8.1): release date, screenshots, features
- McAfee LiveSafe protects PCs, mobiles and the cloud
- Android boss: Samsung's not a problem for Google
- Hands on with the new Google Maps
- Nokia Lumia 925 review: first look
- Why I won't subscribe to Creative Cloud
- GoPro camera strapped to a remote-control helicopter: the ultimate boy's toy
- Acer Iconia A1 review: first look
- Acer Aspire P3 review: first look
- Acer Aspire R7 review: first look
- How we produce the PC Pro podcast
- Google Now draining iPhone battery
- The government website that doesn't work with IE, Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Macs or smartphones