Skip to navigation
Analysis

When will you get superfast broadband?

Posted on 6 Nov 2009 at 15:14

Yet even if you’re offered a free upgrade by BT, you might want to think twice. Ofcom’s recent broadband speed survey revealed that LLU lines are significantly faster than those delivered via BT Wholesale. The speed difference was particularly marked during the peak hours of 8-10pm, when LLU lines were almost 1Mbit/sec faster on average.

“This slowdown during peak hours is the result of contention on the network as multiple users share the same backhaul bandwidth,” Ofcom concluded. “The faster average speeds delivered by LLU operators are likely to be a reflection of the lower cost per unit of backhaul capacity for operators using their own network, compared to the cost of renting capacity from wholesale suppliers (such as BT Wholesale or Cable & Wireless).”

Who will get 24Mbits/sec?

You can check to see whether your telephone exchange is served by LLU providers or is WBC-enabled on SamKnows Broadband’s excellent Exchange Checker. Ironically, those areas served by fibre are most likely to receive ADSL2+, while rural areas may struggle to receive either. Which leaves them with...

8Mbits/sec

Those areas left untouched by LLU providers, Virgin Media or BT’s fibre will be left to slog it out on bog-standard ADSL lines. These are sold as up-to-8Mbits/sec, but even if you squatted in your local telephone exchange, you wouldn’t get a connection faster than 7.2Mbits/sec because BT Wholesale’s Broadband Remote Access Server (BRAS) takes 10% off the line speed to ensure the connection is stable.

And even a 7.2Mbits/sec connection is beyond the realms of fantasy for the majority of people on ADSL. On lines sold as “up to 8Mbits/sec”, the average download speed is only 3.9Mbits/sec according to Ofcom research released this summer – less than half the advertised speed.

So while the lucky few who are connected to BT’s FTTP service can enjoy multiple HD streams into the home, the average ADSL customer would be lucky if their connection was fast enough to stream a single show in HD from the BBC iPlayer, which states that customers need at least a 3.2Mbits/sec connection to keep the streams running smoothly.

Little wonder, then, that BT Total Broadband has resorted to measures such as giving away its iPlate device (now redubbed BT Broadband Accelerator) to help boost broadband speeds.

However, such devices are mere sticking plaster. The biggest obstacle to ADSL speeds remains the length of that copper wire running to your home from the telephone exchange. And there’s little prospect of that being replaced anytime soon.

Who will get 8Mbits/sec?

ADSL remains the dilapidated backstop option for areas that aren’t covered by cable or fibre rollouts, and are still waiting for their local telephone exchange to be upgraded for ADSL2+. Sadly, it’s likely to be the fastest option for many rural areas for some years.

Zero

And then we come to the Have Nots: the many homes and businesses that have no access to broadband, or speeds so despicable that it doesn’t justify the name. Ofcom and BT may proudly boast that 99% of the population is within reach of an ADSL line, but that still leaves tens of thousands of families and rural businesses without access to a decent internet connection.

1 2 3 4 5
Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here

From around the web

User comments

I am in rural highlands of Scotland, I can see my exchange from my window, I still only get 512k connection speeds. BT has checked the line for faults, and that's my lot. Roll on "digital Britain", or at least fewer Windows updates. Try downloading XP SP3 with that speed!

By TiredGeek on 6 Nov 2009

To TiredGreek

yes 512K is slow, however is was only 5 years ago when most people would of thought 512K fast.
Keeping broadband slow in rural areas is keeping the 'working on the net from home' crowd away. Who needs the overpaid buying up all the houses as 2nd or 3rd holiday homes.

By Tibbs on 8 Nov 2009

Virgin cap "Draconian"

Virgin caps users who download more than 3.5Gb in a 4 hour period and then limit them to 2Gb /hr -how is this draconian?

By milliganp on 8 Nov 2009

Tire Greek

If you want fast speed then move away from rural Scotland as it's also likewise crazy to expect a regional hospital or university on your doorstep.

By robbiemca on 9 Nov 2009

Tire Greek

If you want fast speed then move away from rural Scotland as it's also likewise crazy to expect a regional hospital or university on your doorstep.

By robbiemca on 9 Nov 2009

Party like it's 1999

It's encouraging to see that comms companies have learned the lesson of 1999 and stopped imagining new applications that will justify over-investing in back-haul capacity precisely where it's least needed. Multiscreen TV, my eye. Buy Cisco and Corning shares.

By antevans on 10 Nov 2009

Slow Progress

It's take 8 years AND a buyout by Cable & Wireless for my broadband to go from 512K to 2MB, costing £24.99 a month excluding line rental. * Meg is the fastest we can get and that's £79.99!

By Stonedecroze on 17 Nov 2009

Slow Progress - edited

That's 8Meg, not *Meg! I should also point out I live in Guernsey.

By Stonedecroze on 17 Nov 2009

Klem

I am just about to move house from an area served by Virgin where I have a basic package at the 10 Meg speed (whilst my other half watches a movie on cable TV) to an ADSL area, where the online tool suggests that the best I will get is 3.5 and I know it will generally be a fraction of that. Currently downloading the latest Ubuntu release is long as a reasonable coffee break.

I work from home. I regard the lack of progress by BT (mainly) and the government (a close second) as scandalous and negligent. It costs me money.

It is about time that that the self serving barriers to improvement were dealt with.

By kaneclem on 29 Nov 2009

Leave a comment

You need to Login or Register to comment.

(optional)

For more details about purchasing this feature and/or images for editorial usage, please contact Jasmine Samra on pictures@dennis.co.uk

advertisement

Most Commented Features
Latest News StoriesSubscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds

advertisement

Sponsored Links
 
SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010
 
 

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.