Skip to navigation
Analysis

When will you get superfast broadband?

Posted on 6 Nov 2009 at 15:14

To say Virgin milked its speed advantage over the ADSL providers is an understatement. When it first launched up-to-50Mbits/sec, it was charging more than £50 a month to customers who didn’t take the company’s TV services. The price has now fallen to £28 a month this autumn (provided you also rent your phone line from Virgin).

While the numbers look poor, if you compare Virgin to other providers then it’s pretty good

Virgin Media boasts that, unlike the ever-diminishing returns of ADSL, its cable network delivers the headline speeds. Is that true even of the 50Mbits/sec services? Andrew Ferguson, editor of Thinkbroadband.com, says his site’s speedtests show average actual download speeds of around only 30Mbits/sec. “While the numbers look poor, if you compare Virgin to other providers then it’s pretty good,” Ferguson adds.

Virgin also implements a fairly draconian traffic-management policy, which chokes the connection speed of customers who exceed a stated peak-time download limit. So although the lines may well be capable of 50Mbits/sec, that’s unlikely to be the actual speed many customers will see around-the-clock. However, at the time of going to press, Virgin was yet to implement traffic management on the 50Mbits/sec service.

Who will get 50Mbits/sec?

About half the population are covered by Virgin’s cable network – use the company’s postcode checker to find out if you’re in a cable region. Be aware that Virgin’s “off-net” ADSL services only hit a maximum of 20Mbits/sec. A Virgin Media spokesman told PC Pro the company had identified half a million homes to which expanding its cable network was viable, although most of those are “filling in the holes” in areas that already have cable coverage.

40Mbits/sec

While the chances of BT fibre running right to your front door are only marginally better than those of a National Lottery jackpot, it’s far more likely that you’re going to be within reach of the company’s fibre-to-the-cabinet (FTTC) rollout.

BT says the up-to-40Mbits/sec FTTC lines will be available to 10 million homes by 2012, and it’s already announced the names of almost 100 telephone exchanges that will receive FTTC by the beginning of next summer. BT is keen to stress that it’s considering both urban and rural areas with its fibre rollout, although the majority of exchanges that have been announced to date are urban areas already covered by Virgin.

FTTC sees fibre running from the local exchange to the green cabinets you often find on street corners. BT is having to install dedicated fibre cabinets alongside the existing telephone cabinets as part of the rollout (a move that hasn’t gone down well with some of the residents in Muswell Hill, who objected to the “eyesores”).

Consequently, the final stretch of the connection running from the cabinet to your front door is still a twisted copper pair, thus hampering the headline speeds to less than half of that offered by FTTP. It also means connection speeds will degrade over distance, leaving many with lines that fall well below the stated maximum.

1 2 3 4 5
Subscribe to PC Pro magazine. We'll give you 3 issues for £1 plus a free gift - click here

From around the web

User comments

I am in rural highlands of Scotland, I can see my exchange from my window, I still only get 512k connection speeds. BT has checked the line for faults, and that's my lot. Roll on "digital Britain", or at least fewer Windows updates. Try downloading XP SP3 with that speed!

By TiredGeek on 6 Nov 2009

To TiredGreek

yes 512K is slow, however is was only 5 years ago when most people would of thought 512K fast.
Keeping broadband slow in rural areas is keeping the 'working on the net from home' crowd away. Who needs the overpaid buying up all the houses as 2nd or 3rd holiday homes.

By Tibbs on 8 Nov 2009

Virgin cap "Draconian"

Virgin caps users who download more than 3.5Gb in a 4 hour period and then limit them to 2Gb /hr -how is this draconian?

By milliganp on 8 Nov 2009

Tire Greek

If you want fast speed then move away from rural Scotland as it's also likewise crazy to expect a regional hospital or university on your doorstep.

By robbiemca on 9 Nov 2009

Tire Greek

If you want fast speed then move away from rural Scotland as it's also likewise crazy to expect a regional hospital or university on your doorstep.

By robbiemca on 9 Nov 2009

Party like it's 1999

It's encouraging to see that comms companies have learned the lesson of 1999 and stopped imagining new applications that will justify over-investing in back-haul capacity precisely where it's least needed. Multiscreen TV, my eye. Buy Cisco and Corning shares.

By antevans on 10 Nov 2009

Slow Progress

It's take 8 years AND a buyout by Cable & Wireless for my broadband to go from 512K to 2MB, costing £24.99 a month excluding line rental. * Meg is the fastest we can get and that's £79.99!

By Stonedecroze on 17 Nov 2009

Slow Progress - edited

That's 8Meg, not *Meg! I should also point out I live in Guernsey.

By Stonedecroze on 17 Nov 2009

Klem

I am just about to move house from an area served by Virgin where I have a basic package at the 10 Meg speed (whilst my other half watches a movie on cable TV) to an ADSL area, where the online tool suggests that the best I will get is 3.5 and I know it will generally be a fraction of that. Currently downloading the latest Ubuntu release is long as a reasonable coffee break.

I work from home. I regard the lack of progress by BT (mainly) and the government (a close second) as scandalous and negligent. It costs me money.

It is about time that that the self serving barriers to improvement were dealt with.

By kaneclem on 29 Nov 2009

Leave a comment

You need to Login or Register to comment.

(optional)

For more details about purchasing this feature and/or images for editorial usage, please contact Jasmine Samra on pictures@dennis.co.uk

advertisement

Most Commented Features
Latest News StoriesSubscribe to our RSS Feeds
Latest Blog Posts Subscribe to our RSS Feeds

advertisement

Sponsored Links
 
SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010
 
 

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.