Microsoft Expression Web 3 review
in Software
Verdict
Better value than ever, but still lags behind Adobe's web design software offerings
Review Date: 5 Nov 2009
Reviewed By: Tom Arah
Price when reviewed: £102 (£117 inc VAT)
Features & Design
![]()
Value for Money
![]()
Ease of Use
![]()
Thanks to a legacy of standards-flouting authoring tools and browsers, Microsoft doesn't have a great reputation in the world of professional web design. Having ditched FrontPage, however, it's keen to reposition itself as a credible challenger to Adobe's all-conquering Dreamweaver.
Expression Web, the replacement for FrontPage, was originally a standalone page-authoring application, but version 3 is very much a suite, including the latest versions of both Expression Design, for preparing web-optimised graphics, and Expression Encoder, for preparing web-optimised video.
The core Expression Web 3 program also boasts enhanced media integration, including improved import of Photoshop PSD files. Not surprisingly, though, the focus is more on new support for Silverlight 3, Microsoft's all-purpose Flash-killer web format designed for cross-platform, cross-browser playback.
It's now easier to embed Silverlight XAPs in your pages and Web 3 adds dedicated Silverlight-based support for smoothly handling high-res Deep Zoom bitmaps.
Silverlight is capable of many things, but the most relevant here is its handling of video. Previously, you had to prepare video externally, but now Expression Web 3 manages the necessary encoding itself, wrapping the resulting web-optimised video file in a choice of Silverlight player skins.
However, there's a major problem. To see any Silverlight objects embedded in your pages you need to have the Silverlight player installed, and currently fewer than a third of users do (compared with 98% for Flash). You can't even view Silverlight files within Expression Web 3 (although bizarrely, you can preview Flash SWFs). Instead, you need to preview your page in a browser.
Microsoft's solution appears to be Web 3's new Snapshot capability. This lets you see what your page will look like in Internet Explorer 6 and other browser versions you've installed (although not Chrome) from within the Expression Web application. Neither Silverlight nor Flash files are supported in the render, however, and the snapshot bitmap is inherently static, so you can't interact with pages or click through to others.
From around the web
I reverted to EW2
This product seems half baked to me. It crashes when trying to load some complex layouts involving ASP.NET Nested Master Pages. EW2 at least loaded the pages, although they looked nothing like they did in the browser. I find myself using Blend 3 for Silverlight, and a combination of Visual Studio and Expression Web 2 for HTML/CSS.
If anything, this makes for a nice HTML/CSS editor, with its Auto Complete for CSS and HTML, and validation warnings. Forget the WYSIWYG.
The interface is odd too. I don't know if it's WPF like Blend is, but you can see the leftovers of FrontPage 98 lurking in some of the menus.
By ManicMarc on 7 Nov 2009 ![]()
"Microsoft's all-purpose Flash-killer web format designed for cross-platform, cross-browser playback."
If you can afford to alienate millions of Linux users for years as you wait for Moonlight to catch up with Silverlight, go for it.
If not, do your business a favour and put your Silverlight SDKs in the bin.
By zeevro on 13 Nov 2009 ![]()
I've tried it
and there's much to like about it, except that for me at least it is a little bit buggy. It offers a superb coding environment that is more intuitive than the one offered in dreamweaver so I use it mostly for coding.
By cervantes01 on 13 Oct 2010 ![]()
advertisement
- LinkedIn revenue doubles as membership soars
- Kodak kills off cameras
- UK broadband project spending £1m on legal fees
- Microsoft: Windows on ARM won't be sold separately
- Intel pays five hours of profits to settle antitrust case
- Windows 8 on ARM to run desktop apps... but only Office
- Ofcom dithers over plans to tackle broadband slamming
- Data boost bolsters Vodafone revenue
- Google working on cloud storage system
- Lenovo's profit leaps 54% on market gains
- Chrome's shine getting lost in translation
- BytePac: the cardboard hard disk enclosure
- How tech loosens our grip on reality
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- The ultimate guide to passwords
- How Apple lulls Mac owners into a false sense of security
- Privacy - outdated luxury or public necessity?
- Building the bionic man
- The making of open-source software
- Top 10 stupid security stories of 2011
- 10 techs to watch in 2012
- PC Pro's favourite tech products of 2011
- 10 most read articles on PC Pro in 2011
- 50 ways to make your PC better
- Why virtualisation hasn't slowed the growth of data
- How to make Google AdWords work for your business
- The curse of sloppily written software
- Paying for your crimes with Bitcoin
- Behind the scenes: tech support for Formula 1
- The security risk of fat fingers
- Why Windows Phone 7 isn't quite ready for business
- When will Microsoft stop fiddling with Windows 8?
- Flash down the pan?
- Metro Style apps vs desktop applications
advertisement






