HP censured over faulty laptops
By Reuters and Barry Collins
Posted on 19 Mar 2010 at 10:42
China's quality control watchdog claims HP sold faulty laptops and ignored consumer protection regulations.
The General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine said in a statement that after consumer complaints, it had found several models were affected by defective video cards and displays.
The faulty video cards caused overheating, crashes and blank screens on some HP Pavilion DV2000 and Compaq Presario v3000 laptops. Six models including the HP 541 also had problems with their screens, the findings added. The statement did not say how many computers were affected overall.
It's not clear whether the problems are related to the faulty Nvidia GPUs that affected several laptop manufacturers in 2008, including HP and Dell, which had similar problems with overheating.
HP said on Friday it was aware of the watchdog's report. "HP acknowledges the findings of the AQSIQ. We are working on a detailed action plan to ensure all points are addressed and will publicly outline this plan soon," it said, adding its customer care program would look into its customers' needs.
The Chinese watchdog's report said that in its handling of the complaints, HP also ignored rules to protect customers with "three guarantees" of a refund, replacement or repair.
Some 170 people have filed complaints over faulty HP laptops, with their lawyer saying the problems dated back as far as 2007. The group that filed the initial complaint wanted the Government to investigate and order HP to recall all faulty laptops in China, but the watchdog's report fell short of that.
From around the web
oh joy
another place for me to vent my anti-HP fury, and it even mentions my old laptop. my compaq presario v5000 was the worst piece of hardware I have ever bought (wireless stopped working and it fell apart just after the warranty expired), backed up by the worst customer service i have ever experienced, and accopmanied by the worst printer ever invented (also HP). the stress of it probably shortened my life.
Moral: stick with lenovo, the things are built like granite, and yet so light. Aaaah!
By gavmeister on 20 Mar 2010 ![]()
I agree. The problem with HP is, that it has two standards:
- consumer quality
- enterprise quality
As presario range falls into the former one, it is by no means better than products of lesser manufacturers.
Lenovo, on the other hand sells in Europe mostly enterprise quality Thinkpads and Thinkstations. IdeaPads are more common on Asian market. Hence there is no much things to go wrong.
My personal (and very biased) choice is Lenovo as well.
By stasi47 on 21 Mar 2010 ![]()
I didn't realise that China even did quality control let alone had a watchdog for it!
By kingct on 21 Mar 2010 ![]()
faulty goods should be replaced
I see that there has been a class action in USA against Nvidia re the faulty GPU / chip in HP, Compaq, Dell and Apple notebooks / laptops.
Anyone with the same problem in the UK please join me in putting pressure on BBC Watchdog and Trading Standards - when I contacted them before I heard nothing but we shouldn't accept this so need to create some publicity.
Di
By dilbar on 16 Apr 2011 ![]()
advertisement
- Chrome's shine getting lost in translation
- BytePac: the cardboard hard disk enclosure
- How tech loosens our grip on reality
- Hokum watch: Safer Internet Day
- Why I'm deleting Adobe from my PC
- Prepare to be patronised: it's Safer Internet Day
- Dear Sony, Samsung and every other tech company in the world: stop trying to be Apple
- Will Apple's Final Cut Pro X update placate the pros?
- Smartr Contacts for iPhone review
- Switching to Office 365's Outlook Web App
- Why virtualisation hasn't slowed the growth of data
- How to make Google AdWords work for your business
- The curse of sloppily written software
- Paying for your crimes with Bitcoin
- Behind the scenes: tech support for Formula 1
- The security risk of fat fingers
- Why Windows Phone 7 isn't quite ready for business
- When will Microsoft stop fiddling with Windows 8?
- Flash down the pan?
- Metro Style apps vs desktop applications
advertisement
