Skip to navigation

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

// Home / Blogs

Posted on June 6th, 2012 by Steve Cassidy

Don’t rush headlong into IPv6

Server Room

If you dip four links deep from the BBC story about World IPv6 day (that’s today) then you will eventually see a banner headline: “This time it’s for real”.

This is partway down the page at the World IPv6 Launch wesbite, after a surprisingly short list of only 14 participating technology companies, and is about all you’re going to see in the up-front materials that makes any reference to just how long this whole project has been in the works. I think that the simplicity of the statements made is a bit of a breakthrough for the technologists and agencies responsible for IPv6, whose minds are normally preoccupied with the delights of colonic quad notation, rather than easy-to-digest English. Incidentally, on the colonic quads – anyone who has had to explain to uptight clients why their unused, default IPv6 configuration includes FECC:00FF as a valid v6 address will already know just how irritating this whole business really can be.

I won’t recast the kindergarten explanations here, aside from saying that as per usual, Vint Cerf has managed to be technically accurate and commendably short in his blog. What I will say is that I have been spending quite a long time now on another planet entirely (that’ll explain the unanswered phone calls – Ed). I don’t mean by hitching a ride on Virgin Galactic – I mean that I’ve got a pure IPv6 connection, and have had for rather more than a year, and the address allocation I have been given is a /64. This means it has as many bits – and therefore, as many potential unique addresses – as all of Planet Earth, on good old IPv4.

Making a secure network in IPv6 is a whole different mental approach from the old “I’m behind a router so I should be fine” state of mind

I haven’t used more than about four, so far. This is for a couple of reasons. One is that the connection came with an IPv4 address space too; the other is that I’ve found it remarkably difficult to even find bits of hardware or software which implement IPv6 and which might reasonably appear in the average small business network, for me to test on my sparkly new connection. Plus, I really need a means of putting IPv6 traffic into my test device from the far end, and… I haven’t yet come across another truly native IPv6 endpoint I can use for this purpose.

Now, there are workarounds for all these limitations – for one thing, Windows 7 and 8 and the Server releases all support v6 natively. For another, there are many providers who will pretend that you are part of their v6 address space, courtesy of a tunnelling arrangement via v4, so it’s not as if experiments are impossible, just kind of irrelevant for now.

Until the day that your ISP makes a configuration change that includes or imposes v6 on you, you’re highly unlikely to hit any v6 traffic or configuration requirements. However, based on experience I’ve collected in Europe (where v6 adoption has been a lot more rapid, though people I talk to there can’t strictly say why they’ve rushed in), there are grounds for getting to know what the situation will mean for you, because every alteration I’ve had to make so far to IPv4 arrangements kyboshed by v6 have been in a dead panic.

It’s the unexpected that really catches you out; and very often, the ISPs choose to announce their architecture changes in less-travelled parts of their sites, or in newsgroups, or by mailing the contact email address that goes with the affected internet connection. Most of the businesses I deal with have long forgotten those details, and/or never check the ISP’s site or newsgroup (how retro, I hear you say), so it’s always a bit of a shock when stuff starts to move around.

The most worrying scenario is when IPv6 signals a complete overhaul by the ISP, in reality finally imposing a whole load of traffic-shaping and content control which in the old v4 network was loaded into the routers and infrastructure, but which (whisper it quietly) never actually worked. Then what changes isn’t, strictly speaking, anything to do with v4-to-v6 at all; it’s actually everything else about your data and how it reaches you – but they don’t tell you that. Lots of firms who have got away with el-cheapo home-user internet access contracts are, I suspect, about to suffer a very rude awakening indeed from that kind of “upgrade”.

If this kind of root-and-branch reform actually sounds appealing to you (here I am thinking of firms with opinionated, eccentric CEOs and CFOs with strong religious convictions about “computers”), and you are thinking of proposing a wholesale shift to IPv6 as your best way of getting an upgrade done on the back of a bit of FUD for your local Ayatollah, then here is a little word of warning.

One of the major advantages of v6 is global addressing, and the end of network address translation (NAT) as a method of operating your private network, well, privately. Big-time network engineers dislike NAT because it makes their central routers work very hard, while small-time network engineers love it as an easy first step on the road to a secure network. Making a secure network in IPv6 is a whole different mental approach from the old “I’m behind a router so I should be fine” state of mind. Make quite sure you realise what it means to be globally addressable, before you gaily join Vint Cerf and his friends on, as he puts it, the 21st century internet…

Tags: ,

Posted in: Real World Computing

Permalink

Follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

5 Responses to “ Don’t rush headlong into IPv6 ”

  1. Paul C Says:
    June 7th, 2012 at 9:40 am

    We aren’t out of IPv4 addresses yet because a few American universities and large businesses each own a 16 million address block (from the early days when no one could guess what the future had in store).

    You can be sure they are itching to make billions by selling them to all-comers. Let’s say $1,000 each? That’s 16 billion per block. Imagine how much lobbying they would be able to afford, to delay the switch to IPv6.

     
  2. AlanS Says:
    June 7th, 2012 at 5:45 pm

    Drawing the distinction between “big-time” and “small-time” misses a key point. How many physical clients are sitting behind each group of routers providing NAT services. I suspect small might exceed big!

     
  3. Jason Field Says:
    June 8th, 2012 at 1:08 pm

    We use the ISP Andrews and Arnolds and they have been IPv6 for a long time, even running special courses in networking about it. Might be worth trying to get an interview with Adrian who is in charge as they have called v4 legacy for so long I can’t even remember. However they understand v6 a lot better than anyone else I have ever met.

     
  4. Michael Spalter, DrayTek Says:
    June 9th, 2012 at 2:47 pm

    The current rate for aftermarket IPv4 addresses is about USD12 currently. Steve’s quite right that you can’t switch to IPv6…you can only add support to your network and then over time, your traffic and web traffic will shift onto IPv6 as more remote services provide an IPv6 route to their servers which previously only supported ipv4. We DO need IPv6 but as there’s not yet a killer app, no-one is interested enough…I guess we need Rovio to support the new angry birds on Ipv6 only….that’ll do it :-) . However as things get tighter in ipv4 space well start to see carrier class NAT and other such uglies which may be enough to make people run for IPv6…also when ISPs start charging premiums for new IPv4 connections.

     
  5. Laura Bedell-Pearce, 4D Data Centres Says:
    September 7th, 2012 at 9:40 am

    Readers of this article may be interested in our free white paper on the subject (which has been widely published by 3rd parties. White Paper IPv6 – Answering your Questions. You may be asking: What’s involved? And why should I upgrade? You can download it from the 4D Data Centres website: http://www.4d-dc.com/about-us/resources/papers/

     

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

* required fields

* Will not be published

Authors

Categories

Archives

advertisement

SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010