Skip to navigation

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

// Home / Blogs

Posted on January 24th, 2012 by Jonathan Bray

Amazon Kindle Fire review: first look

Amazon Kindle Fire

When Amazon launched the Kindle Fire last year, it made the rather irritating decision not to bring it to the UK at the same time. The rotters didn’t even let us have the Kindle Touch, leaving us with the (admittedly excellent) fourth generation Kindle. If the rumours are to be believed, however, changes are afoot, and with the UK braced to receive Amazon’s latest baby, we’ve managed to get our hands on an import to see what’s what.

Amazon Kindle Fire

Probably the most important thing about the Fire isn’t the hardware, the software or content offering, but the price. With no official confirmation of the launch, we can’t say for sure how much it will be, but in the US it’s $199, and given Amazon’s track record on its E Ink Kindles, we can’t see it costing much more than £200. In fact, it could be less. That’s significant. Where most other manufacturers are using the iPad as a yardstick when it comes to pricing, with 10in tablets costing around £350 to £400, and smaller tablets at around £300 to £350, Amazon is setting out all on its own, with a price more akin to no-brand Chinese knockoffs. The big question is, would you buy one?

The first thing to get straight is that this isn’t a tablet in the traditional sense. Yes, it runs Android (version 2.3), but the user interface is heavily customised. There are none of the ugly smartphone-esque graphics normally associated with cheap tablets – it actually looks attractive – and it works in an entirely different way.

Gone is the usual widget- and icon-littered Android desktop, to be replaced with a bookshelf-themed front-end. Along the top of the screen runs a bar with links to different content categories: Newsstand, Books, Music, Video, Docs, Apps and Web. Below it is a horizontally scrolling carousel of recent items, and this covers not only books and other content, but also apps and web pages. At the very bottom on the screen – on the bottom shelves – is a list of customisable favourites, to which any number of items can be added.

Amazon Kindle FireIt’s a design that makes sense, and the reason it works so well is that it’s driven by Amazon’s content offering. You’ll doubtless be familiar with the company’s ebook and periodical library, but the Fire also provides the opportunity to rent or buy movies and TV shows, and purchase music, with users also able to borrow books using the Kindle library lending service. And with the Fire, that content doesn’t even have to be downloaded and stored locally. As with books on the Kindle, Amazon keeps copies of all purchased content in the cloud, and files can be streamed or downloaded as needed. Files can even be removed and downloaded again later.

We weren’t able to test the whole process of downloading videos and music, unfortunately, as the service isn’t yet live in the UK, but we were able to stream track previews and movie trailers smoothly, and the Kindle eBooks service worked beautifully.

Performance

Clearly Amazon has put a lot of thought into the integration of content, but to hit such a low price it’s abundantly clear that cutbacks have been made. The first casualty is the design. The Fire is a real slab of a tablet, measuring 11.5mm thick and weighing 404g – that may seem fine, but this is a 7in tablet designed for reading books on, and held in one hand it feels unwieldy compared to the best small Android tablets.

Amazon Kindle Fire

There’s also very little in the way of design nicety. There isn’t much a manufacturer can do with the glass touchscreen of a tablet, admittedly, but the rear and edges give it a chance to shine. Amazon has turned down that opportunity. The rear of the Fire is plain black, slightly rubbery plastic, with the word “kindle” etched in counter-relief, while the edges are straight up and down – not a contour nor a chamfered edge in sight.

If the looks are disappointing, the specifications are doubly so. The dual-core Texas Instruments CPU looks fine on paper, but with only 512MB of RAM to back it up, the tablet frequently feels a little ragged and jittery. The user interface isn’t affected too badly, but scrolling up and down, zooming and panning around some web pages (the BBC or YouTube homepages, for instance) is hardly smooth. Here, Amazon’s lauded Silk browser, which loads some page elements server side and attempts to predict what you’ll click on next in a bid to speed up, cannot help. The slight performance lag also affects ebooks, pages of which seem to catch slightly as they’re swiped aside.

Other disappointments include a lack of Bluetooth, no front or rear camera, single-band wireless, no GPS, and limited storage space of 8GB, with no microSD for expansion. There’s no 3G version either, which seems odd, and the resolution of the screen – 1,024 x 600 – lends a slightly grainy look to affairs.

On the positive side, the benchmark figures indicate that the tablet should take most apps and games in its stride. It finished the SunSpider JavaScript test in a time of 2,567ms – not the quickest we’ve seen, but far from poor. It completed the PC Pro HTML render test in an average of 15.5 seconds, which again isn’t bad. Although we weren’t able to use the Amazon app store, we were able to side-load a couple of games and get them running using their APK install files, and both worked smoothly.

Amazon Kindle Fire

Other aspects of performance are more impressive. The screen is a bright IPS model – we measured it at a maximum 414cd/m2, with a contrast ratio of 796:1 – so movies do look punchy and colourful, notwithstanding the low resolution. With the brightness turned down, reading text is easy on the eye too, and with more options for tweaking text than the standard Kindle, the Fire makes a decent ebook reader.

Finally, in our looped video battery test we found the Fire lasted a total of 8hrs 43mins, which is pretty good compared to other Android touchscreen devices of a similar size and with similar specifications. It’s clearly nowhere near the E Ink-based Kindle that can last weeks on a single charge, though.

Prospects

That Kindle Fire, then, is tricky to assess in light of established genres. In the context of other Android-based tablets it looks light in several areas; things we’d normally come down heavily on a normal tablet for. Although the screen is bright, and battery life acceptable, other tablets offer far more power and features, better responsiveness and more attractive design. On the other hand, it won’t satisfy fans of the E Ink Kindles, with their huge battery life and paper-like displays.

Consider it on its own merits, however, and the Fire begins to make more sense. Its inextricable links with Amazon’s services, and its focus on content, in fact, make it more of an iPad-lite than a budget Android knockoff. The cloud-based approach is ingenious, too, and adds an extra dimension.

The key thing, as mentioned at the very beginning of this preview, is the price. If Amazon does bring this tablet to the UK, and it’s around the same cost as it is in the US, it will almost certainly have a winner on its hands. It’s clearly far from perfect, but the low price, coupled with the Kindle name and Amazon’s content services, should be enough to ensure it’s a force to be reckoned with in 2012.

Tags: , ,

Posted in: Hardware, Just in

Permalink

Follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

23 Responses to “ Amazon Kindle Fire review: first look ”

  1. Daoloth Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 1:26 pm

    ..yes but when can I buy it? ;-)

     
  2. SteveE Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 1:40 pm

    I just register my UK Kindle reader with a US address and use all the US services like simple games and a more extensive book list with no problem. You can change country whenever you need to. Would that not work for the Fire too?

     
  3. David Hood Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 1:41 pm

    no idea on price, and no idea on when…

     
  4. carl Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 2:14 pm

    Thinking of buying one from America

     
  5. George Mathioudakis Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 3:47 pm

    I bought one from the States over Christmas and unfortunately I am using it as a very expensive e-reader at the moment. Knew what I was getting into, hoping that Amazon will introduce it quite soon. Still waiting for the announcement though…
    The review is spot on, but for $200, you get what you buy..

     
  6. Jonathan Bray Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 6:04 pm

    SteveE – the whole US address thing does indeed work, but only with ebooks and periodicals.

    We found during testing that the app store, movie and music services all require a credit card that’s registered to a US address or purchases will not complete.

    Jonathan Bray,
    Reviews editor,
    PC Pro.

     
  7. Alan B Says:
    January 24th, 2012 at 11:08 pm

    I’m waiting patiently on the Android 4 tablets before waving my notes.

     
  8. David Staples Says:
    January 25th, 2012 at 9:22 am

    “but to hit such a low price it’s abundantly clear that cutbacks have been made”.

    PC Pro staffers make me laugh.

    [1] Android based attempts at an iPad style tablets are apparently “too expensive” (i.e. the same price as an iPad)
    [2] The Kindle Fire is available at a lower price, but at the cost of cutbacks in certain areas in order to keep the price down.

    Are the writers at PC Pro familiar with the concept of cognitive dissonance?

     
  9. Steve A Says:
    January 25th, 2012 at 9:34 am

    I’m waiting patiently on the Windows 8 tablets before waving my notes.

     
  10. David Staples Says:
    January 25th, 2012 at 9:49 am

    “Gone is the usual widget- and icon-littered Android desktop”

    The icons are still there, they’re just on faux wooden “shelves”.

    “There isn’t much a manufacturer can do with the glass touchscreen of a tablet”

    Apple’s lawyers might disagree.

    “it feels unwieldy compared to the best small Android tablets”

    You mean PC Pro concedes that there might actually BE some decent Android tablets? Y’know, tablets that don’t have the Apple logo on the back?

    “Other disappointments include a lack of Bluetooth, no front or rear camera, single-band wireless, no GPS”.

    Buy a £500 tablet if you want all of that. My Touchpad lacks many of these features too, and it originally cost twice what the Kindle Fire cost (mine was a “fire sale” one BTW).

    “It’s clearly nowhere near the E Ink-based Kindle that can last weeks on a single charge, though.”

    Which is down to the e-ink display, not the battery.

     
  11. BRIAN LEVINE Says:
    January 25th, 2012 at 11:25 am

    Bought the FIRE in USA in December and loved everything except for the fact that you require a US address and credit card to download any games or apps (even the free ones) so I took it back after 15 days and now I am await the UK version, assuming it will be at a similar price, which I will buy and it will be perfect to use with my music system for cloud and NAS drive access.

     
  12. Rob Says:
    January 26th, 2012 at 9:13 am

    Why moan about the lack of a camera?
    This is an ebook, not a tablet. That’s why it’s cheap.

     
  13. chrisski Says:
    January 26th, 2012 at 9:23 am

    I’m glad a big hitter is putting a tablet out with a lower price attached, but I don’t see this as the alternative to just getting an iPad (which I have not). I keep looking at the android derivatives, but so far nothing’s taken my fancy over the apple, so instead I wait impatiently for Microsoft to start shipping Windows 8 – from all the demos I have seen, it is definitely the one for me. Then again, perhaps a Fire could fill the wait…

     
  14. Graham Says:
    January 26th, 2012 at 9:56 am

    This is an ereader that souond like it can make a better job of web browsing than the original Kindle. If you read illustrated publications this will be brilliant. One of the rarely mentioned downsides of the eInk readers is that colour illustrations can be very difficult to interpretdue to the poor contrast. I can see companies equipping service engineers with these.

     
  15. Michael Says:
    January 26th, 2012 at 10:55 am

    But you can now get the Motorola Xoom, running Android 3.2 and already 4 in the USA, for £249 from places like the Carphonewarehouse and Dixons… And it has bluetooth, gps and all the other goodies. And there is a version of the Kindle reader for it.. Always worth paying a few bob extra as long as you don’t got for silly Apple prices!.

     
  16. wittgenfrog Says:
    January 27th, 2012 at 12:50 pm

    The Fire is a kind of ‘third way’ with the MS vision that Tablets are ‘PCs’ (though quite what that means….), and Apple’s half-way house where they are predominantly, but not exclusively consumption devices.

    The Kindle Fire (I think the name is a clue) is a consumption device plain and simple. Hence no cameras etc.

     
  17. Helen Neely Says:
    January 28th, 2012 at 6:03 pm

    I bought one during the Christmas, and most say it’s not what I expected. The RAM is too small and can’t watch BBC iPlayer as flash crashes often. I’ve just resorted to reading books with it – that’s all.

     
  18. David Wright Says:
    February 1st, 2012 at 11:49 am

    @Helen Neely – An Amazon content consumption device, that you are only consuming Amazon content on… Sounds like it is fullfilling its roll nicely. ;-)

     
  19. Humbug Says:
    February 1st, 2012 at 6:00 pm

    The only reason I would by the Kindle fire for is that I would be able to read books with colour plates, e.g. diagrams, pictures etc. Also it is a great asset to have colour capability as I now can subscribe to my fav. magazine too.
    I so not bothered about the lack of a camera, but I am bothered that it has not got 3G as the Kindle range has. Also a shame that the battery life is soo short, when compared with the Kindle.
    Maybe I will wait for the 2nd generation fire, hopefully with 3G, so I can watch the Videos and music, held in the Cloud, on the move.

     
  20. carryonvending Says:
    February 1st, 2012 at 9:37 pm

    Had one since launch. Can’t wait to get full functionality in the UK.
    Had some Browser problems related to SILK or NOT TO SILK and how KF stores bookmarks. When it gets confused the only way to appease it is to reboot or switch Browser on and off. DOT COM said thaey would replace, but I said I would wait for UK to support. Since then Browsing seems to have got better. I was wondering if it could have been a UK Silk Testing problem, as I heard Amazon were gearing up the big switch over for European Cloud (however I meay be miss informed)

     
  21. Crackfellow Says:
    February 6th, 2012 at 10:24 am

    Buy a prepay American Visa or Barclaycard online, register to the address of a US hotel. It works.

     
  22. Crackfellow Says:
    February 6th, 2012 at 10:26 am

    Apologies – for Barclaycard, read Amex.

     
  23. Gregg Jillson Says:
    February 21st, 2012 at 8:41 am

    This is excactly what I was serching for (report)! Gregg Jillson

     

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

* required fields

* Will not be published

SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2010