Posted on March 2nd, 2009 by Barry Collins
The Kindle Swindle? It’s the book publishers who are conning themselves
Luddites of the world unite – you have a new leader. Step forward Roy Blount Jnr, a man who has one too many Os in his surname, in my opinion.
Blount is the president of the US Authors Guild, and last week wrote an opinion column for the New York Times entitled The Kindle Swindle? Blount argued that the new Read-To-Me feature of Amazon’s latest eBook reader was akin to the end of mankind as we know it; a computerised text-synthesiser that was going to leave the audio book industry as burnt out as a carelessly parked Porsche on a South London council estate.
“You may be thinking that no automated read-aloud function can compete with the dulcet resonance of Jim Dale reading Harry Potter or of authors, ahem, reading themselves,” Blount argued. ”But the voices of Kindle 2 are quite listenable.”
No, they’re not. Go to the Amazon Kindle 2 Page, click on the top video and listen for yourself. It sounds like a Dalek that’s been sent on media training. And note that Amazon only lets the speech synthesiser ramble for a sentence or so – probably just before it horribly mispronounced Mr Darcey as “Mister Darkie” and sparked an international race-relations incident.
There’s a reason publishers pay actors such as Stephen Fry, Martin Jarvis and Rob Brydon a healthy wedge to narrate their books – and that’s because no-one wants to listen to Davros reading War and Peace. With the best will in the world, even Stephen Hawking got a narrator in for the audio book of A Brief History Time.
Nevertheless, Amazon has buckled and is now letting publishers decide which novels they wish to be read aloud by the Kindle.
Read my lips, Mr Blount. G-E-T-A-L-I-F-E.
3 Responses to “ The Kindle Swindle? It’s the book publishers who are conning themselves ”
Leave a Reply
Categories
- About the bloggers
- Green
- Hardware
- How To
- Just in
- Microsoft Office 2010
- Newsdesk
- Online business
- Random
- Rant
- Real World Computing
- Software
- View from the Labs
- Windows 7
Authors
Archives
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
advertisement
Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk





























March 2nd, 2009 at 2:05 pm
I whole heartedly agree! How ridiculous Mr Blount is to predict the end of the audio book, just because Kindle 2 has a rudimentary voice synth. This sort of synth has been about for years on PCs and we still read things on screens – surely we would all have tossed our TFTs aside and put on the headphones to browse are emails!
As an avid reader, but also as someone who enjoys audio books while renovating my house, a simple voice synth will not replace a high quality human reader. Maybe the Daleky voice could be used on a Doctor Who audio book?
March 5th, 2009 at 3:54 pm
As an audiobook publisher, I am horrified that Kindle should have even considered putting an audio version, however good or bad, on their machine in view of all the rights issues involved. Do people now think that they can always ride rough-shod over copyright laws. In an age when China is at last coming to terms with the copyright law I find it amazing that the manufacturers of the Kindle should take several steps backwards and do their own version which i can’t even bring myself to listen to. In an age of specialisation, the Kindle is fantastic for reading ebooks but anyone who wants to listen should surely go and buy on CD or download the definitive audio version. We shall take legal action should Kindle decide to give their terrible audio version of any tile to which we have exclusive audio rights.
March 5th, 2009 at 4:30 pm
Clive,
I find your attitude both extraordinary and appalling in equal measure. This isn’t an “audio version”, Amazon hasn’t paid an actor to read aloud your works. It’s a piece of software that interprets text and converts it into speech. If that’s a threat to your audio book sales, you’re hiring the wrong narrators.
Your industry is taking the same, Luddite, wind-up-the-drawbridge approach as the music industry did. Amazon spends money developing a feature that enhances your product, and you’re gut instinct is to sue.
Remember this conversation when you’re looking back a decade from now and wondering where your company went.
Barry Collins
Online Editor