Skip to navigation

PCPro-Computing in the Real World Printed from www.pcpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.pcpro.co.uk/registration.

The newsletter contains links to our latest PC news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

// Home / Blogs

Posted on May 15th, 2008 by Mike Jennings

To Eee or Not to Eee?

I’m in something of a quandary. After seeing just how much work I can get done on the train – there’s an awful lot of time to be had in between businessman having fights with their portable bicycles and then hammering away on their Blackberries – I’ve decided to buy some sort of ultraportable laptop.

The superb Asus Eee PC.

My motivation is that while I’d like to work on the train, getting anything done at the moment requires more effort than I’d like. Which, ideally, is no effort at all. At the moment, hammering out a review on the journey home involves lugging a (relatively) heavy laptop in an extra bag, with the respective power cables in case I decide to use it when I get home, too. I’d like to condense this down somewhat, and some sort of smaller, lighter laptop stands out, as I’d be able to slip it into my backpack with everything else.

Given its runaway success, the Eee PC stands out, but there’s already two models to choose from – the original 701, and the newer, slightly bloated 900. However, both, while being undoubtedly brilliant little machines, come with caveats. The original Eee, for instance, has a screen that could be generously described as cramped and, while I use FireFox and OpenOffice at home, they’re both on Windows XP. The Eee’s custom Linux distribution doesn’t sound like it’ll co-operate with Football Manager, and Windows XP costs a bit more. The keyboard also looks a little cramp for my sausage-sized fingers – my colleague Sasha Muller has warned me away from the 701, as I’ll probably spend most of my time on the train deleting letters that I’ve inadvertently hit.

It’s fair to say that the 901 does address many of these problems. The screen, thankfully, is larger, supporting a resolution of 1,024 x 600. The hard disk can be up to 16GB in size – far better for Football Manager, as well as all that work I’ll be doing – and the Celeron processor now uses all of its 900MHz, as opposed to being clocked down to 630MHz, as it was in the 701. It runs XP comfortably thanks to the doubling of RAM – 512MB to 1GB – and weighs not far over a kilogram. It sounds like the ideal train companion, and one that I can slip into my bag with ease. It’s also a better performer than the original Eee.

However, these improvements come at a price – £280 excluding VAT, to be exact. Which is another sticking point – for not much more than that, I could invest in a genuine laptop with a 13in screen. Back in Issue 161’s Light Laptops Labs, nothing stretched beyond 2kg in weight, with 12 and 13in screens the norm. Almost all of these, though, were far more expensive than the little Eee that could, and benchmark scores indicate that virtually all of them are far more capable performers than the Eee.

And then there’s the raft of pretenders to the Eee’s ultra-cheap, ultraportable crown. MSI’s forthcoming Wind should be arriving in the PC Pro Labs pretty soon, and that is promising to be another contender for my cash. However, the top specifications of that model could cost up to £700 which, again, would buy me a very tasty laptop with a 13in screen and, no doubt, a better specification.

The battlelines have been drawn for my wallet’s affection – the Eee 900 will sate my train-working needs, sure, but the price could be a sticking point when better-specified laptops – I’m thinking larger screens, better processors, hard disks and optical drives – could almost as easily fill a niche in my bag, and be far more versatile and powerful for it.

So, any ideas or clues as to where my cash should go? What’s the best small, light and cheap laptop you’ve seen? I’m open to suggestions.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Posted in: Hardware, Random

Permalink | Trackback

Follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

Social Bookmark this article: What is this?

8 Responses to “ To Eee or Not to Eee? ”

  1. Paul Ockenden Says:
    May 15th, 2008 at 9:47 am

    For an unconventional choice, consider the Nokia N810. Cheap, small, and runs Linux.

    Watch out for the Mobile & Wireless column in issue 166, where I’ve covered this in more depth.

    Might not suit you though, if you have farmers’ fungers.

    P.

     
  2. Paul Ockenden Says:
    May 15th, 2008 at 9:49 am

    or fingers, even!

     
  3. Mike Jennings Says:
    May 15th, 2008 at 9:55 am

    A quick gander on Google has made me think – it’s certainly an interesting looking device and I’m looking forward to reading it in issue 166. I’m guessing it’d be as cheap or even cheaper than the Eee, too.

    Although my ginormous fungers might not agree with the N810’s keyboard!

     
  4. Thought Dan Says:
    May 15th, 2008 at 6:05 pm

    We love our Macs for the train, you can work up your presentations on your way in, and Bluetooth the files between each other.

     
  5. David Morgan Says:
    May 15th, 2008 at 8:42 pm

    I agree that the price on the eeePC 900 puts it into contention with other “serious” laptops. Either wait for competition to drive the price down or consider if you REALLY want portability that much. I did – and chose the eeePC 701. I’m still using on Linux (has made me a convert to Firefox!) although conversion to XP is easy. Keyboard is ok unless you’re a touch-typist, but add a travel mouse for convenience. Can easily be modded to run at full 900 Mhz without overheating/ damage (plenty of info on ‘net, and after all that’s exactly what the newer 900 does in a similar-sized case!) Just stick in 1Gb of RAM (if you buy the 4G model, there’s a panel on the underside to remove and plug the SODIMM replacement in – won’t even invalidate your warranty). Add an appropriate SDHC card to the side-slot and go for it! I’ve several good computers networked at home and have a DELL Latitude D620 for on the move – but the eePC is so easy to carry around that it’s probably gettting as much use as any of them! It’s taken over from my PDA for most things. Biggest issue for me is that’s it’s SOOO portable that I’m now very conscious of anywhere that’s short of WiFi hotspots…!

     
  6. Alan Says:
    May 16th, 2008 at 10:43 am

    Another problem might actually be getting an eeepc 900.

    I just asked for a quote from a leading supplier on an eeepc 900 with XP and was advised-

    “That?s not in stock and will not be with us for at least 4 months as there are back orders from Asus since dec 2007″

     
  7. Mike Jennings Says:
    May 16th, 2008 at 10:47 am

    Wow. That’s some backlog – looks like I won’t be getting an Eee PC for a while, if at all. After further consideration and consultation, it seems like my fingers will probably be too elephantine for the Eee after all, so I’m beginning to look at 12 and 13in laptops. The Acer Aspire 2920 looks decent.

    Then again, there’s a raft of new, cheap ultraportables approaching. Do any of these, besides the MSI Wind, take your fancy?

     
  8. FireWolf Says:
    May 17th, 2008 at 2:48 am

    Mike, I purchased the EEE PC (701 w/2gb of ram, and Xandros still on her) to semi replace my HP Pavillion DV5215US (15.4″ widescreen).

    I did this for 2 reasons:

    1) I needed a laptop that didn’t weigh a ton, was easily portable, and had more features than the ipaq PDA’s I had with wifi or my worthless motorola Q phone with windows mobile.

    and 2) I wanted a windows alternative especially considering I refuse to upgrade to Vista and XP will go to the way side sooner than I’d like.

    A couple of things come to mind that I can share as they relate to laptop comparisons.

    Sure, the keyboard is smaller, and maybe weird getting used to. Case in point is the #1 key. There is no tilda key next to the one, so that throws me off a bit LOL. When I touch type, it is a learning adjustment. But if you are looking at a computer with portability and size matters, than a 7″ laptop can meet those needs.

    Using my EEE PC for router work is also wonderful and size does matter when stuck in cramped closets.

    The one thing I didn’t like about PDA’s was that stupid stylus. I can type faster with a keyboard, and it feels natural to me. Sure, I had bluetooth keyboards, and IRDA but you thought the EEE PC had a tiny keyboard LOL.

    My HP Pavilion stays at home all the time now. I use my EEE PC as an Ebook reader, internet surfer, email, skype, word processing documents on the fly (w/ open office), the only thing I wish Asus would get behind is finding some better games for it LOL (I need more than sudoku and ltris)

    Aside from that, yes I have a portable cd-rom (usb) device for things I need to run off cd, but most of my other applications, etc, run from my 8gb sdhc cards (I have 2) as well as some extra 2gb sd cards I have lying around.

    You get used to the smaller screen, but it’s hella bigger than a PDA or phone, and while some windows won’t format right, you deal with it. I expect things will smooth out and the crafty coders will come out with apps and mods to make this an even more enjoyable experience.

    That’s all I have for ya, hope it helps hearing from a 701 owner. I plan on keeping my EEE PC for it’s lifetime as there is nothing out there that can touch it!

     

Leave a Reply

* required fields

* Will not be published

Categories

Authors

Archives

advertisement

SEARCH
SIGN UP

Your email:

Your password:

remember me

advertisement


Hitwise Top 10 Website 2008